Kathleen Hallinan
Vice President, Litigation
Sony Pictures Entertainment
10202 West Washington Blvd.
Culver City, California 90232-3195
PH: 310-244-6948
Sept. 15, 2015
Dear Kathleen:
Thank you, again, for your lovely letter.
We have been thinking about you as we read all of the news disclosures, investigations, public comment, Wikileaks, HollyWood Reporter and federal research material about Sony Pictures.
When we contacted you. We asked you to come to the table to have a reasonable discussion about a massively documented issue. The issue of Sony Pictures defrauding us, breaching signed agreements, stealing product and, generally being pretty nasty people. We thought we might have misunderstood something. We hoped you would take even one meeting, or phone call, to discuss the problem, and clarify any potential misunderstandings. According to you: Sony Pictures refused to even have a discussion.
We had really hoped that you guys didn’t turn out to weasels. After reading all of the news about how you rigged your movies for political gain, hated on women and people of color, ran an elitist political funding program from within your organization, a bunch of you had to hit the bricks, paid off politicians, did sketchy things with tax filings, acted like high school children when the other kids got a bigger serving of potatoes, and, just really showed your dark side, it kind of seems like the whole world thinks you are bad guys. You know what they say: “KARMA IS A BITCH!”
Yah, Yah..we know your staff told us to “just sue you”, knowing that it costs $300K to fire that up, but we would still like to avoid that. Certainly we would love to sue you if we can find a great contingency litigation firm who will go after you on a contingency fee basis. In the meantime, we want you to know that we found quite a bunch of other artists, technologists and performers who say “you screwed them over too”. You seem to have a hard time making friends, don’t you?
As you know, this was not a case of us feeling like you might have used “our stuff”. You called us up, invited us down, downloaded our knowledge, reviewed our notes and technology, signed a bunch of contracts and secrecy agreements with us (all of which you breached), copied our stuff (we found your documents where you openly admitted it to the Federal Government), changed our trademarks to yours, and have now made billions of dollars off of things the United States Government says you stole from us. Your leaked documents say you lied about it to us and the markets. Your staff put their names on our stuff after telling us, in numerous emails, that they would protect us; not to worry, be patient, etc. Before your staff ran off to run NPR, they lied. You pretended to be about to buy us, when you were merely using that as a sham to acquire our internal technical knowledge. We now have it all in writing.
The records now prove that you first heard about the technology from us. You had no internal, or contract, projects in the works, until you invited us to present at your Board Meeting. You spent months with us. If only we had known you were just trying to copy our stuff. You tricky little monkey’s.
So, we have made certain that this is going to go on forever. We will never give up fighting for our rights and our justice in this matter. Everybody on Earth will eventually know about what you did.
As you know, we have sued your “partners” and brought everybody from the FBI, The GAO, 60 Minutes and 300 million+ voters in on that one. They have paid dearly. There is a funny thing about “bad guys”, it turns out NOBODY LIKES THEM! For all of history; you can be the David Sarnoff to our Philo Farnsworth. Is that the branding that you want? Eternity is a long time. History books last forever in the digital age.
Get right. Stop being weasels. Grow some ethics and come to the table.
Very Truly Yours,
The Team
PS: This article seems to really nail it on the head:
“SEEKING LAWYER TO SUE SONY PICTURES; HAVE PRE-KOREAN EVIDENCE OF NAUGHTY DEEDS BY SONY”
By Tony Dime – AV Web News
The kids at Sony seem to have been very naughty children. They let their IT system go to pot, and got hacked, and outed, as “racist”, “misogynist”, “campaign rigging”, “high school tantrum throwing” kinds of people, per their own emails. Hollywood Reporter, The Verge, Wikileaks, and a variety of tabloids and pundits, have delighted in dissecting the fraternity house, inside antics, of Sony Pictures. Their boss got fired. They got ridiculed for turning “Zero Dark Thirty” into a, slightly fabricated, political vote-churn tool. Other execs got kicked to the curb. All of their financial, contracting, political cash layout, and tax dynamics were placed under investigation, and even more sketchy bits are shaking loose…
Then I saw this ad online: “SEEKING LAWYER TO SUE SONY PICTURES; HAVE PRE-KOREAN EVIDENCE OF NAUGHTY DEEDS BY SONY”. My curiosity drew me to look into this.
The latest issue has to do with Sony’s hope for its future. The movie box office numbers, from walk-in theaters, are not so swell. The world has discovered, and embraced, digital media. Netflix users are going up, up, up and print media is dead. Sony’s future depends on digital media.
Sony is rushing to play catch-up with Sony Vue Video-on-Demand and VR headsets to watch digital movies in. Other content owners are worried about Sony being in charge of their digital content, if Sony can’t even keep its own digital house in order. Documents from the hacks, and whistle-blowing from past employees and investment banks, confirm that Sony has spent many billions on it’s digital video program and intends to make vast billions of dollars off of digital video-on-demand.
Sony was not always in a jam to try to get digital done right. In 1998 Sony approached a small technology group (Let’s call them “ABC Group”) in San Francisco, which had developed the first full-screen web video. The technology was the first to deliver full screen, high definition, full frame-rate, full color, small data demand, movies and music, over the internet, using any standard browser. For their demonstrated accomplishments, “ABC Group” had received TV news coverage, feature print news article acclaim and even a White House commendation. “ABC” had the first version of “youTube” working, online, before “youTube” even existed.
No other company had done this exact thing before, nor had anybody patented it, and demonstrated it, nor did anyone have this much of a leg up on it, like “ABC Group” had. “ABC Group”, accurately, predicted that movies on the web, and their technology approach, would be a “big thing”.
This was before YouTube, Napster, Bittorent, iTunes, Vudu, or the rest, had even been formed. One of this group’s biggest pitches was that their movies were un-hackable, because their technology allowed them to put thousands of digital padlocks throughout each movie, so that no hacker would even bother with the hassle of trying to open all of those locks. Today, Sony appreciates that factor more than ever.
Sony had kept it’s eye on this group, since this group first developed, built and patented, the first wearable VR headset movie system. Sony’s Director of Worldwide Pay-Per-View: Lawrence Hess; Sony’s Vice President of Marketing: Ira Rubenstein; Sony’s Manager of Corporate Development: Steven C. Tsai; Sony’s Vice President of Sales & Advertising for Pay Television & Airlines: Cheryl Koll; and Sony’s Director of Marketing: Andrew Schneider; contacted the heads of “ABC Group” and said that they wanted the technology and invited “ABC” to come to Sony Headquarters in Los Angles to make a full board presentation.
At one of the multiple (recorded) meetings with senior Sony staff, there were so many Sony Executives, many of whom had flown in from Japan, that many were shaking hands, for first-ever meetings, and commenting: “Oh, you are the head of so-and-so department, I read about you in Variety all the time.”
In addition to the above, other Sony luminaries at the discussions included: Sony’s Vice President of Post Production Services: Patricia Furnare; Sony’s Director of Marketing for Sony Semiconductor: Thuy T. Nguyen; Sony’s Product Marketing Manager for Consumer a/v/d for Sony Semiconductor: Grace Wei; Area Sales Manager for Sony Semiconductor: Jerry K. Smith; Sony Vice President of Corporate Development: Patrick Kennedy; Sony Vice President of Business & Legal Affairs: Eric I. Baum and other top Sony leaders.
During one of the largest meetings, a fight broke out between Sony executives in which one group said, about “ABC’s” technology: “We must stop this, it could destroy our business plan”; while another group yelled out: “We must do this, it is the business plan of our future.”
“ABC” demonstrated their Playstation-like video cartridges and gamebox/video player web connected hardware box and software. Many, many non-disclosure agreements, and contracts, were signed by Sony pictures, but were later found to have been broken by Sony executives.
After dangling “investment” and “acquisition offers” and requiring extensive “investment review” of the technology, Sony later says: It is “too early to talk about this”…. It is a bit too “futuristic”…” Essentially a “Thanks, but no Thanks”.
“ABC” had many “how to” meetings with all of the key Sony engineers and executives. Extensive numbers of highly encouraging emails, letters and contracts were exchanged. All of those documents and communications have now been recovered and this reporter has viewed many of them. It looks, now, like all of the meetings were simply “fishing expeditions”, by Sony, to get free lessons in how to build the technology. Sony executives had always promised “ABC”: “Don’t worry”, “We will take care of you”… but they never did.
Years later, “ABC” discovers a patent that Sony had rushed out to file, right after one of the largest meetings with “ABC”. The man who had first solicited “ABC” on behalf of Sony: Sony’s Vice President of Marketing: Ira Rubenstein; had listed himself as the “inventor” on Sony’s patent application. The Sony patent application described a clone of the “ABC” technology. Many of the other Sony executives, from those meetings with “ABC”, had also put their names on the patent as “co-inventors”. “ABC” always found this sudden inventive spirit by Mr. Rubenstein to be amazing, since, at the same time, he was sending emails to the founders of “ABC” describing himself as a “computer idiot” and lamenting his inability to get technology to work.
This was the same Ira Rubenstein who stood on stage at the Variety Entertainment Magazine industry-wide event, and proclaimed to the heads of the entertainment industry, that: “The future of the web will be brought to you by Sony Pictures and “ABC Group”…” As he pointed to “ABC Group” staff standing in the room. He said this on-camera, on behalf of Sony Pictures.
Sony’s patent filing, and their later digital music and video roll-outs, turned out to be complete copies of the system ABC had engineered, built, launched, demonstrated and patented. As history now shows, Sony went right out and copied the technology, as soon as they got done sifting through “ABC’s” intellectual property.
In an even more profound slap in the face: when forensic intellectual property experts scoured Sony’s federal patent files, they found an ironic smoking gun! In Sony’s own patent files, submitted to the U.S. Government, the hired Sony patent writers, who had drafted the patent, had accidently left in the written notations about “ABC Group”! In all of Sony’s patent materials, then, the only outside source of inspiration mentioned was “ABC Group”. Sony’s own, federally filed, patent notes prove where Sony got their engineering and intellectual property from: “ABC”
Sony’s own materials, again, come back to bite Sony in the butt, after the Korean hack. It turns out that what they had said that digital media exploitation was making was not what the true number, it was much, much higher. Web video was making more than Sony had said, and Sony planned big profits, in the next years, off of that single technology shift. Everyone enjoyed seeing all of the South Pacific Island trips, private schools and multiple homes that Sony executives were always bragging about. That digital media exploitation sure pays well. “ABC” was curious about when their money from Sony might show up so they could, also, get a private beach house in Tahiti. Ironically, if Sony had used “ABC’s” hack prevention technology on its own corporate files, the hackers from Korea never would have been able to hack Sony’s corporate files.
After seeing some of the newer confirming documents, “ABC” asked George Clooney’s agent, a man who Sony, at one time, respected, to assist with negotiating a settlement. Sony’s CEO, though, was facing extraction, and that potential settlement deal did not evolve.
To date, according to Sony documents, and Staff, Sony has made over $18 Billion+ dollars exploiting “ABC’s” technology. Sony has paid “ABC” and its lead staff exactly ZERO!
Big companies tried to stop, hit-job, blockade and blacklist ABC from getting “those damn movies on that internet”; but it is now the main way that people see media. It is no longer possible for Sony to say the technology couldn’t have worked. It is working in Sony’s own products.
Current Sony lawyers say that they were not around “back then” and that Sony has “No obligation”. The records, recordings and documents tell a different story. “ABC” wrote the head of Sony Corporate in Japan. They advised him that Sony executives were being dishonorable. He has yet to reply.
“ABC” is looking for a law firm to sue Sony. Suing Sony is a pricey proposition and Sony knows this. That is why Sony used to be quite cavalier about their actions around the use of the property of artists, performers, musicians and technologists. In these post hack days, though, with hard evidence on the table, maybe they will change their tune.
The value of a big corporation is its brand. If the brand of Sony is tied to remarks and actions about racism, women, ego’s and idea theft, then Sony has a long row to hoe. Sony might want to do the right thing here and finally return “ABC”’s phone call. Sony Vice President of Litigation: Kathleen M. Hallinan; said that “ABC” was too small to take Sony on and refuses to even have a single discussion about the matter. “ABC” bet their lives on this technology to improve the lives of the world. They were solicited and hood-winked by Sony, who then made vast amounts of money off of “ABC” without every paying “ABC”. The facts and evidence proves this. Sony’s arrogance, as shown in their emails, clearly demonstrates why they have the attitide they have, but the public are fickle agents when it comes to corporate insincerity.
Will this ever go away? “ABC” says: “Never!.. not until we get a fair discussion.”
Sony just launched their Sony Vue copy of ABC’s technology so the clock has a long time to run. Sony has now publicly delivered the technology that “ABC” created, without paying “ABC” a dime.
Sony, why won’t you do the right thing and try to work this out? “ABC” is preparing a picket line, in front of your corporate offices, with big bright signs, banners and websites, for providers that you did wrong. They have found quite a few others. Harrassement and hit-jobs, against those who are just trying to get paid, are never going to cut it. See more at http://www.stiffedbysony.com
If you are an experienced law firm, and you want to sue Sony Pictures on behalf of “ABC”, and split the winnings, let me know and I will forward your info to “ABC”.
Filed under: TOP NEWS Tagged: Kathleen Hallinan, Now More People Think Sony Sucks!, Sony hack, sony pictures 
