Bismillah hirRahmaan nirRaheem
With The Name of ALLAH, The Beneficent and The Merciful
SallALLAHU A’la Muh’ammad SallALLAHU Alayhe Wasallam
The Differences Among The Religions in Islam
Islam me Madhhab ka Ikhtilaaf
By Dr. Gibril Fouad Haddad
1 Al-Hafiz al-Bayhaqi in his book “al-Madkhal” and al-Zarkashi in his “Tadhkirah fi al-ahadith al-mushtaharah” relate: Imam al-Qasim ibn Muhammad ibn Abi Bakr al-Siddiq said: “The differences among the Companions of Muhammad (s) are a mercy for ALLAH’s servants.Al-Hafiz al-`Iraqi the teacher of Ibn Hajar al-`Asqalani said: “This is a saying of al-Qasim ibn Muhammad who said: ‘The difference of opinion among the Companions of Muhammad (s) is a mercy.
2 Al-Hafiz Ibn al-Athir in the introduction to his “Jami` al-usul fi ahadith al-rasul” relates the above saying from Imam Malik according to al-Hafiz Ibn al-Mulaqqin in his “Tuhfat al-muhtaj ila adillat al-Minhaj” and Ibn al-Subki in his “Tabaqat al-Shafi`iyya.”
3 Bayhaqi and Zarkashi also said: Qutada said: “‘Umar ibn `Abd al-`Aziz used to say: ‘It would not please me more if the Companions of Muhammad (s) did not differ among them, because had they not differed there would be no leeway (for us).'” 4 Bayhaqi also relates in “al-Madkhal” and Zarkashi in the “Tadhkira”: Al-Layth ibn Sa`d said on the authority of Yahya ibn Sa`id: “the people of knowledge are the people of flexibility (tawsi`a). Those who give fatwas never cease to differ, and so this one permits something while that one forbids it, without one finding fault with the other when he knows of his position.”
5 Al-Hafiz al-Sakhawi said in his “Maqasid al-hasana” p. 49 #39 after quoting the above: “I have read the following written in my shaykh’s (al-Hafiz ibn Hajar) handwriting: ‘The hadith of Layth is a reference to a very famous hadith of the Prophet (s), cited by Ibn al-Hajib in the “Mukhtasar” in the section on qiyas (analogy), which says: “Difference of opinion in my Community is a mercy for people” (ikhtilafu ummati rahmatun li al-nas). There is a lot of questioning about its authenticity, and many of the imams of learning have claimed that it has no basis (la asla lahu). However, al-Khattabi mentions it in the context of a digression in “Gharib al-hadith” . . . and what he says concerning the tracing of the hadith is not free from imperfection, but he makes it known that it does have a basis in his opinion.'”
6 Al-`Iraqi mentions all of the above (1-5) in his “Mughni `an haml al-asfar” and says: “What is meant by “the Community” in this saying is those competent for practicing legal reasoning (al-mujtahidun) in the branches of the law, wherein reasoning is permissible.”
Tweet Me
NOTE: What `Iraqi meant by saying “the branches wherein reasoning is permissible” is that difference is not allowed in matters of doctrine, since there is agreement that there is only one truth in the essentials of belief and anyone, whether amujtahid or otherwise, who takes a different view automatically renounces Islam. (Shawkani, “Irshad al-Fuhul” p. 259 as quoted in Kamali, “Principles of Islamic Jurisprudence” p. 383.) Al-Albani in his attack on the hadith “Difference of opinion in my Community is a mercy” ignores this distinction and even adduces the verse: “If it had been from other than ALLAH they would have found therein much discrepancy” (4:82) in order to prove that differences can never be a mercy in any case but are always a curse. Al-Albani’s point is directed entirely against those who are content to follow a madhhab. The only scholar he quotes in support of his position is Ibn Hazm al-Zahiri, whose mistake he adopts without mentioning it was denounced by Nawawi. (“Silsila da`ifa” 1:76 #57)
7 Ibn Hazm said in “al-Ihkam fi usul al-ahkam” (5:64): “The saying “Difference of opinion in my Community is a mercy” is the most perverse saying possible, because if difference were mercy, agreement would be anger, and it is impossible for a Muslim to say this, because there can only be either agreement, or difference, and there can only be either mercy, or anger.” However, Imam Nawawi said in his Commentary on “Sahih Muslim”: “If something (i.e. agreement) is a mercy it is not necessary for its opposite to be the opposite of mercy. No-one makes this binding, and no-one even says this except an ignoramus or one who affects ignorance. ALLAH the Exalted said: “And of His mercy He has made night for you so that you would rest in it,” and He has named night a mercy: it does not necessarily ensue from this that the day is a punishment.”
8 Al-Khattabi said in “Gharib al-hadith”: “Difference of opinion in religion is of three kinds: – In affirming the Creator and His Oneness: to deny it is kufr (disbelief); – In His attributes and will: to deny them is innovation; – In the different rulings of the branches of the law (ahkam al-furu`): ALLAH has made them mercy and generosity for the scholars, and that is the meaning of the hadith: “Difference of opinion in my Community is a mercy.” Al-Jarrahi cited it in “Kashf al-khafa” 1:64 #153.
9 Al-Hafiz al-Suyuti says in his short treatise “Jazil al-mawahib fi ikhtilaf al-madhahib” (The Abundant Grants Concerning the Differences Among the Schools): “The hadith “Difference of opinion in my Community is a mercy for people” has many benefits among which are the fact that the Prophet (s) foretold of the differences that would arise after his time among the madhahib in the branches of the law, and this is one of his miracles because it is a foretelling of things unseen. Another benefit is his approval of these differences and his confirmation of them because he characterizes them as a mercy. Another benefit is that the legally responsible person can choose to follow whichever he likes among them.” After citing the saying of `Umar ibn `Abd al-`Aziz already quoted (#3 above), Suyuti says: “This indicates that what is meant is their differences in the rulings in the branches of the law.”
10 The muhaddith al-Samhudi relates al-Hafiz Ibn al-Salah’s discussion of Imam Malik’s saying concerning difference of opinion among the Companions: “Among them is the one that is wrong and the one that is right: therefore you must exercise ijtihad.” Samhudi said: “Plainly, it refers to differences in legal rulings (ahkam). Ibn al-Salah said: “This is different from what Layth said concerning the flexibility allowed for the Community, since this applies exclusively to the mujtahid as he said: “you must exercise ijtihad,” because the mujtahid’s competence makes him legally responsible (mukallaf) to exercise ijtihad and there is no flexibility allowed for him over the matter of their difference. The flexibility applies exclusively to the unqualified follower (muqallid). The people meant in the saying: “Difference of opinion in my Community is a mercy for people” are those unqualified followers. As for the import of Malik’s saying “Among the Companions is the one that is wrong and the one that is right,” it is meant only as an answer to those who say that the mujtahid is able to follow the Companions. It is not meant for others.””
11 The author of “al-Fiqh al-Akbar” (attributed to Imam Abu Hanifa) said: “Difference of opinion in the Community is a token of divine mercy.”
12 Ibn Qudama al-Hanbali said in “Al-`Aqa’id”: “The difference in opinion in the Community is a mercy, and their agreement is a proof.”
Discussion
The decision of `Umar whereby he gave precedence to `Ubayy ibn Ka`b’s ijtihad over the ijtihad of `Abdullah ibn Mas`ud on the validity of praying in a single garment is not a proof that `Abdullah was wrong, rather it is a proof that `Umar exercised his own ijtihad and authority as the Greater Imam in settling the question. He overruled, not invalidated, and if Ibn Mas`ud held his position from the Prophet (s) he cannot change it even after `Umar’s ruling. This is true of every true mujtahid at any time: he is obligated to follow the result of his own ijtihad even if it should differ with that of every other mujtahid of the past and present, unless he becomes convinced that he was mistaken in his previous ijtihad.
According to all the scholars it is incumbent upon the leader of the Muslims to be a mujtahid and it is his responsibility in such cases to settle the question for the sake of the people of his time, and that is the proper context of Imam Malik’s injuction: “Exercise ijtihad.” It is addressed to the mufti who must establish what is correct in clearcut fashion, not to themuqallid (follower) who is only interested in “a way to follow” (= madhhab) without having to verify its proofs and inferences. However, another mufti may reach another conclusion and be followed, and is not bound by that of the first, nor are those who take their fatwa from him, and no-one finds fault with the other, as Al-Layth ibn Sa`d stated.
A clear proof that the fatwa of the leader overrules but does not invalidate the opinion of the Companions even if it directly contradicts it, is the fact that when `Umar ibn al-Khattab proposed to have all the hadith collected and written down he consulted the Companions and they unanimously agreed to his proposal; later he disapproved of it and ordered that everyone who had written a collection burn it. Yet `Umar ibn `Abd al-`Aziz later ordered that hadith be collected and written. Al-Hafiz al-Baghdadi relates it in his “Taqyid al-`ilm” 49, 52-53, 105-106, and Ibn Sa`d in his “Tabaqat” 3(1):206, 8:353.
Those who think they are mujtahid but in reality are unqualified, when faced by the followers of madhahib, cover up their ignorance with the flashy claim: “We follow Qur’an and Sunna, not madhahib.” When it is pointed out to them that to follow a madhhab is to follow Qur’an and Sunna through true ijtihad, they become upset: “How can the four madhhabs differ and be right at the same time? I have heard that only one may be right, and the others wrong.” The answer is that one certainly follows only the ruling that he believes is right, but he can never fanatically invalidate the following of other rulings by other madhahib, because they, also, are based on sound principles of ijtihad. At this they rebel and begin numbering the mistakes of the mujtahids: “Imam Malik was right in this, but he was wrong in that; Imam Shafi`i was right in this, but he was wrong in that . . . ” This is what they say, and what they hide in their heart is worse because it includes even the Companions. This we will never accept. But when they are rebuked for this blatant disrespect they make it known that they have been wronged and “They are arrogant in their sin” (2:206). This is nothing else than the legacy of the Wahhabi/Salafi movement.
Blessings and Peace on the Prophet, his Family, and His Companions. May ALLAH be well pleased with the Four Mujtahid Imams, and all the scholars who feared ALLAH truly.
All Feedbacks are whole-heartedly welcome!
Shukriya to ruknulislam!
Filed under: Differences Among The Religions in Islam Tagged: 2014 convert to islam, a muslim women, about islam religion, about islamic, about islamic religion, about muslim, about muslim religion, about muslim women, about of islam, about the islam religion, accepted islam, accepting islam, against muslim religion, all about islam, all about islam religion, all about muslim, all about muslim religion, all about the muslim religion, all islamic prophets, all islamic wallpaper, all muslim, all muslim prophets, all world muslim, allah muslim religion, american converts to islam, are all muslim islamic, articles about islam, articles about islam religion, articles about muslim religion, articles islam, articles of islam, articles on islam, articles on islamic religion, articles on muslim religion, beautiful muslim images, beautiful muslim wallpapers, beautiful muslim wife, beautiful women muslim, black muslim religion, books on muslim religion, can you convert to islam, christianity and islam, christianity in islam, christianity islam, christianity muslim, christianity or islam, christians convert to islam, christians in islam, concept of islam, conversion to islam, convert from islam to christianity, convert in islam, convert in islam 2014, convert in muslim, convert islam, convert islam 2014, convert muslim, convert to islam 2014, convert to islam religion, convert to muslim 2014, converting into islam, converting to islam 2014, converts to islam, converts to islam 2014, creation islam, creator of islam, differences among the religions in islam, differences islam, download muslim, dream interpretations in islam, dreams islamic, eid muslim 2014, evil religion islam, fake religion islam, festivals of islam, free muslim, free muslim matrimonial, from islam to christianity, great islamic images, great islamic stories, great islamic story, great islamic women, great muslim women, how convert to islam, how do i convert to islam, how do you convert to islam, how old is islam religion, how old is islamic religion, how old is muslim religion, how old is the islam religion, how old is the islamic religion, how old muslim religion, how to convert in islam, how to convert in muslim, how to convert into muslim, how to convert islam, how to convert muslim, how to convert to a muslim, how to convert to islam, how to islam, how to join islam, how to muslim, how to revert to islam, i love islam quotes, i love muslim images, i love muslims, image for muslim, image of muslim, images for muslim, images muslim, images of muslim, images of muslim religion, important muslim women, information about islam religion, interpretations of dreams in islam, is islamic a religion, is the muslim religion evil, islam & christianity, islam a fake religion, islam a religion, islam an evil religion, islam and christianity, islam and society, islam and the world, islam and world, islam articles, islam as a religion, islam chat, islam convert, islam converts, islam converts 2014, islam current news, islam evil religion, islam fake religion, islam great religion, islam greatest religion, islam in the world, islam in the world today, islam in world, islam is a religion, islam is an evil religion, islam is evil religion, islam is fake religion, islam latest news, islam makkah, islam muslim religion, islam news stories, islam on christianity, islam one, islam page, islam religion, islam religion articles, islam religion books, islam religion news, islam religion of evil, islam religion rules, islam religion today, islam religion youtube, islam revert, islam slave, Islam The Great, Islam The Great Religion, islam to christianity, islam view, islam world news, islamic channel, islamic christianity, islamic christians, islamic convert, islamic converts, islamic download, islamic festivals, islamic festivals 2014, islamic islamic, islamic kaaba, islamic link, islamic matrimonial, islamic muslim, islamic new, islamic pages, islamic real stories, islamic real story, islamic religion, islamic religion rules, islamic revert, islamic revert stories, islamic story, islamic tags, islamic things, islamic true stories, islamic true story, islamic verses, islamic view, islamic wallpaper 2014, islamic world news, issues in islam, join islam, know about islam religion, know islam, list of islamic prophets, love and islam quotes, love in muslim, love islam quotes, marriage in muslim religion, married in islam, married muslim, meaning of dreams in muslim religion, messenger of islam, more about islam, muhammad in muslim, muhammad in muslim religion, muhammad muslim religion, muhammad prophet picture, muhammad prophet story, muslim a religion, muslim against muslim, muslim and christians, muslim and women, muslim articles, muslim as a religion, muslim beliefs, muslim brother and sister, muslim categories, muslim channel, muslim chat, muslim chat room, muslim chat rooms, muslim christianity, muslim convert, muslim convert marriage, muslim convert to islam, muslim convert women, muslim converts, muslim converts marriage, muslim creation, muslim culture, muslim date, muslim dating, muslim download, muslim dreams, muslim dua, muslim eid, muslim eid 2014, muslim evil eye, muslim faith, muslim girl photo images, muslim image download, muslim images, muslim images download, muslim in the world today, muslim in world, muslim is a religion, muslim islam religion, muslim islamic images, muslim issues, muslim ladies, muslim love images, muslim love wallpaper, muslim mariage, muslim marriage images, muslim married, muslim message, muslim messages, muslim month today, muslim months, muslim muslim, muslim muslim muslim, muslim news stories, muslim now, muslim one, muslim online, muslim or islam religion, muslim pages, muslim pic, muslim prayer, muslim prophet, muslim prophet stories, muslim prophets stories, muslim religion, muslim religion images, muslim religion in the world, muslim religion is evil, muslim religion islam, muslim religion marriage, muslim religion rules, muslim religion wallpaper, muslim revert, muslim revert marriage, muslim s, muslim stories, muslim story of creation, muslim t, muslim true stories, muslim verses, muslim wallpaper, muslim wallpaper download, muslim wallpaper images, muslim wallpaper photos, muslim wallpapers, muslim wallpapers download, muslim wallpapers images, muslim weddings, muslim wife, muslim wives, muslim woman, muslim woman image, muslim women, muslim women beautiful, muslim women convert, muslim women image, muslim women images, muslim women in america, muslim women pic, muslim worship, muslims and women, muslims in america, muslims religion, muslims wallpaper, muslims wallpapers, muslims women, my religion is islam, name islam, name islamic, name of the prophets in islam, new convert islam 2014, new convert muslim 2014, new convert to islam, new convert to islam 2014, new converts to islam, new converts to islam 2014, new islam, new islamic quotes, new islamic stories, new muslim convert, new muslim converts, new muslim converts 2014, new muslim images, new muslim reverts 2014, new muslim stories, new muslim story, new muslim women, new muslims, new revert to islam, new revert to islam 2014, new to islam, new to islam religion, new to islam website, news about islam, news about muslim in the world, news for muslim, news muslim, o islam, one islam, our holy prophet s.a.w, our religion islam, pic islamic, pic of muslim, pilgrimage islam, pilgrimage muslim, prayers muslim, prophet of islam religion, prophet of islam stories, prophet of muslim, quote islamic love, quotes about islam and love, quotes about islamic love, quotes in islam about love, quotes islam love, real muslim women, real story of islam, recent converts to islam, recent reverts to islam 2014, religion in islam, religion in muslim, religion islam or muslim, religion islamic, religion muslim, religion muslim or islam, religion of islam, religion of muslim, revert in islam, revert islam, revert muslim, revert muslim stories, revert stories islam, revert to islam, revert to islam 2014, revert to islam stories, revert to islam youtube, revert to muslim, reverted to islam 2014, reverted to islam stories, rules in muslim religion, rules of islam religion, rules of islamic religion, rules of muslim religion, rules of the muslim religion, sayings of islam, society in islam, status about islam, stories of islamic prophets, stories of muslim prophets, story about islam, story islam, story of islam religion, story of islamic, story of islamic prophets, story of muslim, story of muslim prophets, story of muslim religion, the great islam, the islam religion, the islamic religion, the muslim religion, the muslim woman, the prophets of islam, the religion islam, the religion muslim, the religion of islam, the religion of muslim, the world of islam, things to know about muslim religion, to convert to islam, to islam, top 10 islamic websites, top muslim women, true stories of islam, true story of islam, wallpaper for muslim, wallpaper muslim, wallpapers muslim, what is a muslim religion, what is islam all about, what is islam religion, what is islamic religion, what is muslim religion, what is muslim religion all about, what is the islam religion, what is the islamic religion, what is the muslim religion, what is the muslim religion about, what is the muslim religion all about, what is the religion of islam, what is the religion of muslim, what religion is islam, what religion is muslim, who is allah in muslim religion, who is allah in the muslim religion, who is muhammad in muslim religion, who is muhammad prophet, who is the muslim prophet, why convert to islam, women in muslim, women muslim, world of muslim