True Mate:
← Older revision
Revision as of 06:35, September 5, 2013
(3 intermediate revisions by one user not shown)
Line 182:
Line 182:
Why do people keep saying she drowned? She didn't. If you guys re-read what happened, it wasn't just the water that killed her. To say she drowned is an assumption, because there were also multiple other factors that played a major part in her death, including old age, the dogs, and the pressure of the water itself. She ''fell off a cliff'', for StarClan's sake. I don't think her death should say "drowned", because that's clearly not what happened. Read the prologue of ''Bluestar's Prophecy'' again. If she drowned, would she have been able to speak or anything because of the water in her lungs? I don't think so. If her mind had been deprived of blood for too long and she died because of that, she wouldn't have been able to speak, let alone apologize to her kits. {{User:Cloudskye/Sig2|16:52,8/27/2012}}
Why do people keep saying she drowned? She didn't. If you guys re-read what happened, it wasn't just the water that killed her. To say she drowned is an assumption, because there were also multiple other factors that played a major part in her death, including old age, the dogs, and the pressure of the water itself. She ''fell off a cliff'', for StarClan's sake. I don't think her death should say "drowned", because that's clearly not what happened. Read the prologue of ''Bluestar's Prophecy'' again. If she drowned, would she have been able to speak or anything because of the water in her lungs? I don't think so. If her mind had been deprived of blood for too long and she died because of that, she wouldn't have been able to speak, let alone apologize to her kits. {{User:Cloudskye/Sig2|16:52,8/27/2012}}
+
+
Yes, Bluestar didn't just drown, although the water that she coughed up after falling into it didn't help her have a longer life. It even says in her Super Edition prologue that she ''nearly'' drowns, not that she does. There were many factors that played a part in her death. Falling off a cliff could kill Twolegs with the force of impact on ground, and even jumping into the river from the cliff's height could extremely hurt when you hit the water in the wrong way with the pressure. Also, she was getting old, and the injuries that the dogs gave her wasn't good for her.[[User:Mistystar31|Mistystar31]] ([[User talk:Mistystar31|talk]]) 06:32, September 5, 2013 (UTC)
+
+
After reading her Super Edition, I have always had one question. Goosefeather told her ''"Like fire, you will blaze through the forest. But beware: Even the most powerful flames can be destroyed by water."'', and Oakheart offered to teach her how to swim after she taught him to climb a tree. Bluestar denied his offer because she was scared of water after hearing her uncle's prophecy. '''However, if Bluestar had learned how to swim, do you think that she would have lived after falling into the river with the dog pack, able to safely swim to land and not flail around in there?'''[[User:Mistystar31|Mistystar31]] ([[User talk:Mistystar31|talk]]) 06:32, September 5, 2013 (UTC)
== UPSET ABOUT TIGERSTAR MUCH??????? ==
== UPSET ABOUT TIGERSTAR MUCH??????? ==
Line 301:
Line 305:
So who do you think was the correct mate for her? <span style="font-size:13px;line-height:21px;">Oakheart and Bluestar truly loved each other, although they did the best for their Clans and "temporarily" broke up. Their love started like her friendship with Crookedstar, and if </span>''he''<span style="font-size:13px;line-height:21px;"> </span><span style="font-size:13px;line-height:21px;">was willing to continue his friendship, they could have mated instead. And if she never interacted much with either RiverClan warriors, Bluestar most likely would have mated with Thrushpelt; this however would mean she most likely would not have been able to get rid of her kits in a good way and become deputy, thus causing Thistleclaw to make a lot of trouble for ThunderClan.</span>
So who do you think was the correct mate for her? <span style="font-size:13px;line-height:21px;">Oakheart and Bluestar truly loved each other, although they did the best for their Clans and "temporarily" broke up. Their love started like her friendship with Crookedstar, and if </span>''he''<span style="font-size:13px;line-height:21px;"> </span><span style="font-size:13px;line-height:21px;">was willing to continue his friendship, they could have mated instead. And if she never interacted much with either RiverClan warriors, Bluestar most likely would have mated with Thrushpelt; this however would mean she most likely would not have been able to get rid of her kits in a good way and become deputy, thus causing Thistleclaw to make a lot of trouble for ThunderClan.</span>
−
<span style="font-size:13px;line-height:21px;">So who do you think, regardless of Clan loyalty and deputy problems, was Bluestar's best mate choice? This includes Crookedstar, thinking if he had remained friends and later mates with her.</span>
+
<span style="font-size:13px;line-height:21px;">So who do you think, regardless of Clan loyalty and deputy problems, was Bluestar's best mate choice? This includes Crookedstar, thinking if he had remained friends and later mates with her.[[User:Mistystar31|Mistystar31]] ([[User talk:Mistystar31|talk]]) 06:35, September 5, 2013 (UTC)</span>