JEFFERSON CITY, Mo. — Auditor Tom Schweich released an audit today of the state’s low-income housing tax credit program. He credited the program as a force in Missouri economic development, but is encouraging changes to enhance the program as it progresses.
“We’ve been able to give more than 40,000 people homes because of this program,” Schweich said. “As a matter of public policy, that is a very, very good thing.”
Rep. Chuck Gatschenberger
Schweich and some lawmakers say the state’s LIHTC program doesn’t create enough economic benefit for its cost, but the program’s defenders say that quantifying the benefits is not always easy.
Many conservative lawmakers are against eliminating the programs, saying eliminating it would allow more money to flow directly to government coffers to foster new state spending.
“There are some very effective tax credits, and we need to keep in mind that the state needs more jobs economic development more than we need to fund more Department of Revenue databases or more DNR regulators,” Chuck Gatschenberger, R-St. Charles County, said.
According to the audit, only about 42 cents of every dollar spent actually goes into construction, and among LIHTC programs, Missouri’s is the largest in the country.
“Having our most vulnerable citizens living in quality, affordable housing has a value more than the ROI model,” said Rep. Vicki Englund, D-St. Louis County. “What is the ROI on the Department of Conservation or the Department of Public Safety? These programs all have a benefit to our citizens and I look forward to supporting them under Governor Nixon and in three years under Governor Koster.”
Executive Director of the Missouri Workforce Housing Association and former Missouri State Senator, Jeff Smith, is a vocal proponent of the LIHTC program. He says that the assertion that Missouri’s LIHTC program is the most expensive in the nation is not accurate.
Rep. Vicki Englund
“In New York City, they have the rent subsidization program that, by itself, is almost a billion dollars,” Smith said. “It serves a very similar purpose to Missouri’s LIHTC program, but it’s different. So this audit — and audits in the past — haven’t taken that into account. There are many, many states with programs that far exceed Missouri’s cost.”
Smith went on to say that much of the value created by LIHTC projects is simply never calculated accurately. When neighborhoods see revitalization after new housing projects, or when seniors are given a cheaper alternative than a Medicaid-funded nursing home, local communities see a positive impact that is hard to quantify in an audit, he says.
“It’s about one-quarter of the cost to put a senior citizen in a LIHTC project than in a nursing home,” Smith said. “Kids in LIHTC buildings are far more likely to graduate and, therefore, far less likely to be imprisoned or require taxpayer-funded benefits. And those benefits aren’t easy to calculate on an audit like this, but we are getting a very good return on investment.”
Hyde Park LIHTC development
The program, which began under Gov. John Ashcroft and was enhanced by the legislature under Gov. Mel Carnahan in 1997, has been used more then the legislature originally calculated. “The [Missouri Housing Development Commission] has allocated essentially 100 percent of the federal amount since 1998,” according to the audit.
Rep. Jeff Roorda
“We wanted lawmakers to have this data in front of them going into break so they would have time to review it,” Schweich said. “There’s going to be a substantial debate about how to make these programs more efficient and we want to contribute to that by providing some data and making some recommendations.”
But not every lawmaker sees a problem with the program.
“If Tom Schweich wants to tell us what laws to pass, he should run for the General Assembly,” Rep. Jeff Roorda, D-Barnhart, said. “Historic and low income [tax credits] have been responsible for tremendous economic growth and job creation in this state for many, many years.”
Rep. Robert Cornejo
Schweich is planning two more audits to be released in the next month on the historic preservation tax credit and the Brownfield tax credit. Schweich said that he decided to audit the three programs last year when it became evident that the legislature would be debating tax credits during session.
“There are few tax credit programs that are beneficial to the state but LIHTC happens to be one of those programs that spurs investments and helps grow communities,” Rep. Robert Cornejo, R-St. Charles County, said. “Growing communities benefits everyone from improving schools to an educated workforce spurring economic growth.”
Other Stories You Might Enjoy:
Schweich releases audit on Solid Waste Management Program
Nixon holds first meeting with black caucus, promises to…
Nasheed blocks PSC appointment, wants LIHTC funds released
Senator Lager Begins His Quest to Cap Tax Credits
Thomas Schweich Q&A Part 2: Issues Facing Missouri
The post Schweich rates LIHTC program as “fair” — lawmakers more optimistic appeared first on The Missouri Times.