writer’s note: i write in lower case, it’s my small rebellion.
i’m mad. i’m mad that gender rules that dictate what is “appropriate dress” for female and male bodies have me thinking about surgically altering my body.
i love my body.
i love how it’s feminine and masculine at the same time. i love the curve of my belly and the muscle line when i flex my triceps. i love how my hips and butt hold my pants up because i let them hang down well below where my waist really is. i love my back and my shoulder blades. i love my chest, especially when my shoulders drop, and i let my heart come forward. and i love my breasts, all size c of them. i like how they look naked, and they are an important part of sex for me. okay, now i’m blushing a little. i have never considered chest surgery, never thought that that was for me. however, i also desperately want to be able to be in public without a shirt or sports bra.
i’m talking about at the beach, playing sports, working out, and stuff like that, not just wandering around the city shirtless. anyway, i can’t do that because i have breasts. so there it is, my contradiction. and for the first time ever. i find myself in a serious conversation with myself, wondering if i want to have chest surgery. but i shouldn’t have to surgically alter my body to be able to feel the sun and air on my bare chest, just because that chest also happens to have breasts.
there’s this age that it happens, i think all girls and especially girls that identified as “tomboys” are familiar with it. if you’re lucky you might get until you’re 11, but for most girls the body policing starts much earlier than that. one minute you’re spending your summers half-naked running through the neighborhood (being careful to stay on your block though), climbing trees, playing in sprinklers, riding big wheels, getting hella dirty, and having all the fun with your cousins and neighborhood friends living around your grandma’s house. life couldn’t be any better because it’s summer, school is out, it’s finally f*cking hot out, and you can stay outside playing with your neighborhood friends until the streetlights come on. and then one day, without warning, you’re suddenly “too old to be runnin’ around here half-naked, especially with all them boys.” it’s almost like it happens overnight, and maybe not even almost. literally, one day you wake up and your body has somehow overnight become a shameful thing that now needs to be covered at all times. even though it’s summer, school is out, it’s finally f*cking hot out, and you’re still just a kid trying to stay outside playing with your neighborhood friends until the streetlights come on.
More Radical Reads: Shaping Gender Norms: How You Can Help Society Break Out Of The Binary
i’ve always identified as mixed gendered, because it feels like two spirit to me without engaging in cultural appropriation. mixed gendered captures both the feminine and masculine energies inside me that get expressed in different ways at different times. my body is female and incredibly feminine and i love that. at the same time, i have a very strong masculine energy and part of me is very much male. in 2011, i started using ‘he, him, his’ as pronouns, although i haven’t actually told everyone in my life that yet. i’m working up to it though, and i’ve already planned a facebook post. or maybe a tweet. four years ago i started packing pretty much every day, because no matter how hard i wish and pray, i can’t seem to grow a penis.
over the years my understanding of my gender and therefore it’s expression have grown and shifted as i make space for the boi in me, and allow him to come forward even more. however, i’ve never considered physically altering my body through hormones or surgery. for my journey around gender, surgery felt counter intuitive to the ways in which i’m committed to living in those mixed and blended spaces. until now. and i hate that i’m even having these questions, thoughts, and conversations.
current gender rules that girls and women are socialized under shame our bodies, while at the same time sexualizing and controlling them for profit. we all know this. or, you know, most of us know this. yet what i don’t know is how to break out of the rules and be my full self, without either risking my safety or changing my body to fit what a male/masculine chest is “supposed to look like.”
we fight back against gender policing, violence, and oppression. we work for transformation and liberation. however, we are not there yet. i can’t be in a public space (even at the beach in 106 degree weather) bare-chested with breasts, without facing possible violence, arrest, and sexual harassment. even if i’m feeding a baby with my breasts, i am not safe. even if i identify as a mixed gendered boi, i am not safe. we all saw the recent harassment and shaming of Muslim women on beaches in france. they were fully covered on the beach and still not safe from harassment and violence because the practice of gendered body policing and shaming is so intense and pervasive. especially for women of color, queer, trans, and gender queer people existing outside of the binary.
so right now i am feeling very confused about how to fully express my gender and my joy in a way that stays true to who i am, in a world that doesn’t want me to do either.
i navigate the daily policing of my body, including what bathroom i’m able to use, while also still acknowledging the very real privileges that my body holds. being able to pass is a privilege. being able to pass without having to physically alter my body is a privilege. being able to pass as male gives me access to male privilege. all of that is very real and true. at the same time that i hold these privileges, i also hold the ways in which my body, whether or not i pass as male, and how i do are intensely policed. i breathe and then widen to hold both the contradictions, and the possible consequences for stepping outside of those lines. especially as a Black queer mixed gendered nonbinary female bodied boi, living in a world that wasn’t designed for me to exist.
More Radical Reads: Masculinity Doesn’t Belong to Any Gender and Other Reasons Why Policing Sexuality Does Not Work
i am an aquarius, so i like to think about things a lot, it’s in my nature. here is the cycle my thought process is going through so far, a kind of pros and cons list if you will:
the surgery would allow me to more freely express my complex gender and boihood in the ways that i want to and feel comfortable.
f*ck gender, gender policing, and gender rules.
having the surgery would increase my ability to pass as male in more situations of my life.
f*ck binaries and traditional notions of male and female bodies that make passing necessary, or even a thing.
i am privileged to be able to live in a place where i could access the surgery relatively easily.
f*ck capitalism and the medical industrial complex and how they feed off of the policing and shaming of women of color, queer, trans, and gender queer bodies.
it would be so awesome to feel the sun and wind on my bare chest without having to worry about being seen or harassed.
f*ck having to alter my body for the comfort of others.
i don’t know what to do, but i’m clearly having a lot of feelings about this.
having the surgery won’t stop the complexities of living and expressing my gender in this world…or the feelings.
that’s where i’m at right now, no closer to making a decision one way or another or to dismantling patriarchy, gender binaries, or gender policing. So the struggle continues on, it most certainly is real. thanks to facebook memory, i was reminded of this poem that i wrote 7 years ago. i was at the very beginning of the newest part of my gender journey, and having some of the same feelings and questions.
seven years later, i still don’t have all of the answers, however, i am definitely not in the same place. i am grateful for that, and for the space and ability to keep questioning this journey as i figure out how to live my gender fully, joyfully, and unapologetically.
*
for all of you also fighting for self-determination and to be your authentic self, here is a little poem…enjoy.
shirtless
why.
can i not go shirtless on the beach
like the other bois do
why.
must i cover my chest
and bind my breasts
to make you more comfortable
and me more decent
why.
when my skin wants to feel hot sun
and warm wind just the same
when my naked back and chest are
no more sexual than “a real boy’s”
why.
when i still remember half-naked cape cod summers
chest covered by sea salt and sand
humid sticky boston nights too hot to sleep
even after ice cream cool water baths stripped clothing
and nanie’s “last warning!”
***
At The Body is Not An Apology, we fight oppression everyday by promoting radical visibility. Please sign up and learn more about #NoBodiesInvisible campaign and new subscription service soon launching from TBINAA.
Need some help growing into your own self love? Join us for our free webinar 10 Tools for Radical Self Love.
[Feature Image: A dark skin individual is submerged in a body of clear blue water floating on their back with face peering through the water. Flickr.com/Ken Bosma]