We've written a few times about how the FBI has been doing a bang up job foiling its own terrorist plots, so we're a bit skeptical every time we see headlines of some giant "terrorist bust." Almost every time, once you dig into the details, it involves some gullible, confused suckers who had no actual connection to terrorists, but were led along by FBI agents and informers until they were "convinced" to take part in a "plot" that was entirely concocted by the FBI. The latest headline-grabbing case of "arrested terrorists" actually appears like it may have slightly more substance, however, in that they may have actually had some sort of connection to al Qaeda and the Taliban in Afghanistan.
That doesn't mean that there still aren't some oddities in the case, however. As a number of folks have sent over, reading through the indictment (also embedded below) shows that a significant chunk of the "evidence" seems to consist of Facebook "likes" and shared content among the accused. From the indictment:
I have reviewed several of the social media web sites
for KABIR, SANTANA, DELEON, each of whom has posted radical prom
jihad content on their respective pages. Additionally, portions
of the social media show that DELEON and SANTANA "liked"
postings on KABIR's Facebook page as early as May 2011.
Public items posted by KABIR to his social media
accounts include photographs of himself, non-extremist content,
radical Islamist content, and items reflecting a mistrust of
mainstream media, abuses by the government, conspiracy theories,
abuses by law enforcement, and the war in Afghanistan. KABIR's
radical postings include videos and links to videos of Al-Qa'ida
leader Anwar Al-Awlagi and his lectures, jihad--based videos
regarding Afghanistan and elsewhere, videos depicting mujahideen
fighters in Afghanistan and elsewhere, videos depicting
terrorist training camps and related activities, videos
depicting improvised explosive device attacks, and
articles regarding the death of American soldiers in
Afghanistan. For example, on July 6, 2012, KABIR shared a video
to his public Facebook page entitled "Knights of Khorasan
Islamic Emirate Operation Against an Army Base in
Margha." This video, which I have reviewed, depicts a suicide
bombing operation against a large base wherein the suicide-
bomber drives an explosives-laden truck into a base and
detonates it. The video bears the symbol of As-Sahab, Al--
Qa'ida's media wing, in the lower right corner.
KABIR has "shared" several postings with SANTANA
and/or DELEON, both of whom have "liked" or commented on several
other postings by KABIR, including the following:
a. On December 7, 2011, KABIR posted a video
entitled "Black Flags of Khorasan: Part 2" that he later
"shared" with DELEON.- (Based on my training and experience,
conversations with other agents, and research of publicly
available information, the black flag or banner refers to a
traditional flag flown by Muhammad and later by Islamic military
leaders. More recently, several jihadi groups and terrorists
have adopted the black flag as a symbol for jihad and mujahideen
fighters.)
b. On or about January 5, 2012, KABIR shared a link
regarding negotiating with the Taliban. SANTANA "liked" the
post and SANTANA and KABIR engaged in a public exchange of
comments. SANTANA said, "they messed up know?" KABIR followed
SANTANA's comment with a comment that appeared to
include excerpts of a "Statement of Islamic Emirate of
Afghanistan," which discussed the Taliban's desire to expel the
United States from, and establish their own government in,
Afghanistan. SANTANA replied to KABIR's comment by writing "Oh yea!!!!"
c. On January 5, 2012, KABIR posted a photo on his
Facebook page depicting a veiled and covered woman leaning on an
assault rifle. DELEON and KABIR exchanged comments on the photo
wherein DELEON said "...hey bro are coming back? whats goin
on? how long gona stay there?" KABIR replied "Naa.. not comin back... movin 4wd.... =D.... 1/2
way 2 my destination.. =D."
(Based on the context of this statement, including the fact that
KABIR was then in Germany, I believe that KABIR intended to
inform DELEON that he had commenced his journey to Afghanistan.)
d. On January 19, 2012, DELEON "liked" a shared link
posted on KABIR's page of a video entitled "Dua of Sheikh
Muhammad al Mohaisany masjid al haram makkah." The video, which
I have reviewed as posted on KABIR's page, appears to be a
prayer for the success of the mujahideen and features various
photos including Al--Qa'ida leaders Usama Bin Laden and Ayman al
Zawahiri, 9/11 attacks, bloodied adults and children, and
Islamic fighters. The video also calls for the liberation of
Al-Aqsa, the mosque referenced in the 1998 Al-Qa'ida fatwa
described above.
e. On February 13, 2012, SANTANA "liked" two shared
video links on KABIR's page, including one for a video entitled
"Imam Anwar al Awlaki -- A Story of Courage."
f. On May 28, 2012, KABIR posted two stories
regarding the death of Al-Qa'ida leader Usama Bin Laden. DELEON
"liked" both stories; SANTANA "liked" one.
g. On June 16, 2012, SANTANA "liked" a video,
produced by Al--Qa'ida's media wing, As-Sahab, shared by KABIR to
his Facebook page entitled "Ghuraba." This video, which I have
reviewed, appears to depict life as a mujahideen fighter and
includes several interviews. The video also features mujahideen
fighters firing artillery.
h. On July 5, 2012, KABIR posted a photo featuring
Al-Qa'ida leader Anwar Al-Awlaqi which contained a quote from
Al-Awlaqi. DELEON "liked" and "shared" the photo.
i. On September 16, 2012, DELEON "liked" KABIR's shared link to a video entitled "The Truth Has Come and Falsehood has perished Part 1 Urdu." This video, which I have reviewed, is a production by As-Sahab and begins with footage of Al-Awlaqi and discusses the war in Afghanistan. The video also features current Al-Qa'ida leader Ayman Al-Zawahiri.
On September 17, 2012 SANTANA "liked" KABIR's post of an article entitled "A Public Talk by Ustadz Abu M Jibriel AR: The Truth of The 9/11 Jihad Operation, The Plots Of The Enemies and The Zionist Conspiracy."
There is, of course, other evidence including statements made by all the defendants. For all we know they may have actually been planning attacks on US targets and the indictment is entirely appropriate. But it certainly gives pause to suggest that "likes" and "shares" on Facebook are somehow evidence of terrorist intent. It could certainly be seen as having a chilling effect for anyone who might "like" or "share" content on Facebook that is critical of the US government.
Permalink | Comments | Email This Story