2015-07-08

News

Sports

Life

Money

Tech

Travel

Opinion

Settings

Full Forecast

Crosswords

Your Take

Investigations

Video

Stocks

Apps

Best-Selling Books

Classifieds

College

Corrections

Interactives

Newsletters

Photo Galleries

Portfolio Tracker

Scores

Race Together

Video Network

Web to Watch

Your Take

Newsstand

Audio

Search

User

Get the news

Log In or Subscribe to skip

132

1

Share This Story!

Let friends in your social network know what you are reading about

Redskins trademark ordered cancelled by federal judge

The Washington Redskins lost in court Wednesday when a federal judge ordered the Patent and Trademark Office to schedule cancellation of six federal trademark registrations owned by the NFL franchise.

Post to Facebook

{#

#}

Sent!

A link has been sent to your friend’s email address.

Posted!

A link has been posted to your Facebook feed.

Join the Nation’s Conversation

To find out more about Facebook commenting please read the Conversation Guidelines and FAQs

Erik Brady, USA TODAY Sports 2:11 p.m. EDT July 8, 2015

UP NEXT

03

A federal judge has ordered the Patent and Trademark Office to cancel registration of the Washington Redskins’ trademark, ruling that the team name may be disparaging to Native Americans. The judge said the organization could keep its name.
USA TODAY

A federal judge ordered the cancellation of six Redskins trademark registrations on Wednesday.(Photo: Geoff Burke, USA TODAY Sports)

The Washington NFL team lost in court Wednesday when a federal judge ordered the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office to schedule cancellation of six federal trademark registrations owned by the club, ruling that the team’s name — “Redskins” — was disparaging to a significant composite of Native Americans when the marks were originally granted.

U.S. District Judge Gerald Bruce Lee emphasized that the team remains free to use the name as it chooses and that the ruling means only that the team loses the specific legal protections of its federal registrations, which remain in effect until all potential appeals in the case are heard.

Lee’s ruling affirms the findings of the patent office’s Trademark Trial and Appeal Board, which last year ruled in favor of Amanda Blackhorse and four other Native Americans who sought cancellation of the registrations. The team had sued in district court to overturn that ruling.

The team is likely to appeal Wednesday’s decision to the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Richmond. The team did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

USA TODAY

Brennan: Ruling on Redskins’ nickname reinforces the inevitable

“Today’s ruling by the District Court resoundingly affirmed the Trademark Office’s decision that the team’s trademark registrations should never have been issued,” attorney Jesse Witten said in a statement. He represents Blackhorse and the other petitioners in the case.

Lee rejected the team’s contention that trademark cancellation infringes on its free-speech rights. “The federal trademark program is government speech and is therefore exempt from First Amendment scrutiny,” Lee wrote in the conclusion of his 70-page ruling.

The team argued in a hearing before Lee last month in Alexandria, Va., that it could not be proved that a significant composite of Native Americans found the term “redskins” disparaging during the years that the federal registrations were granted. But Lee ruled that “the evidence before the Court supports the legal conclusion that between 1967 and 1990, the Redskins Marks consisted of matter that ‘may disparage’ a substantial composite of Native Americans.”

Those legal terms — “significant composite” and “may disparage” — come from the Lanham Act, which bars federal trademark registration for marks that may disparage or bring into disrepute particular groups or individuals. The original trademark case against the team using the Lanham Act came in 1992, when Suzan Harjo led a group of Native Americans who challenged the federal registrations.

USA TODAY

Washington Redskins appeal decision to cancel trademark

The patent office’s appeals board ruled in favor of Harjo and her fellow petitioners in 1999, but the team appealed in federal court and won in 2003 when the court ruled the petitioners had waited too long after turning 18 years old to file their complaint. The Blackhorse case, which began in 2006, used younger petitioners. Lee ruled against the team’s argument that the Blackhorse petitioners waited too long not only by citing their ages, but “because of the public interest at stake.”

Even if the team were to lose all appeals, it could continue to enforce its trademarks in state courts and under common law. But team attorney Robert Raskopf argued in last month’s hearing before Lee that losing the circled R that comes with federal trademark registrations would be a significant blow to the team, which has invested money and goodwill in its marks for decades.

The decision also figures to be a loss for the team in terms of public relations. The fight against the team name, which goes back decades, was re-energized last year when the patent office’s appeals board issued its ruling.

TOP VIDEOS

‘The Dominican’ [trailer]: Alex Garcia UFC fighter series

Elite 11 QB Camp attracts top prep talent

Judge orders Redskins trademark to be cancelled

MLB Fantasy Focus: Hisashi Iwakuma’s value

Biggest winners in NBA free agency

The Edge: McGregor vs Mendes

FSU punch debate: Is it ever okay for men to hit back?

NBA Daily: How are draft picks playing in Summer League?

How to clean your kicks, according to the world’s biggest sneakerhead

How did classic football game Tecmo Super Bowl save your stats?

Meet the world’s biggest sneakerhead

NFL Daily Blitz: Andre Johnson will make impact with Colts

ShowBiz Minute: Knight, Miss USA, Jenner

Hole-by-hole: PGA’s Barbasol Championship in Opelika

Herica Tiburcio enjoying the life of an Invicta FC champion

Nothing personal for Irene Aldana, but there’s work to be done against Tonya Evinger

Tonya Evinger wouldn’t go to the UFC, even if they called

Faith Van Duin admits she’s nervous, but not about fighting ‘Cyborg’

Cristiane Justino hopes Bethe Correia kicks Ronda Rousey’s ass

Austin Dillon’s horrifying Daytona crash in his own words

Fan Perspective: will McGregor’s hype bubble burst at UFC 189?

Conor works out in Ultimate Fighter Gym and preps for his time to shine

MLB Fantasy Focus: Replacing injured big home run hitters

UFC 189 Unibet’s Inside The Octagon – Robbie Lawler vs. Rory MacDonald

Best to Watch This Week with Greg Fitzsimmons

NFL Daily Blitz: Will Pierre-Paul miss start of season?

NBA Daily Hype: Latest in free agency

NOS Energy Drink Fight Breakdown: Conor McGregor vs. Chad Mendes

World Cup: Congratulations Team USA!

Jessica Aguilar on champ Joanna Jedrzejczyk, Claudia Gadelha

Watch fans all over America go crazy as U.S. wins WCup

Make your own ‘eagle fan’ costume for $142.67

MLB Fantasy Focus: Who’s the hottest pitcher in baseball?

Passionate fans fill with pride during World Cup Soccer watch parties

Twitter wants World Cup hero Carli Lloyd for president, $10 bill

Fans celebrate USA’s World Cup win

NBA Daily Hype: Texas big free agency winners

2015 Women’s World Cup: Abby’s last run

2015 Women’s World Cup: Hope Solo’s tumultuous victory

2015 Women’s World Cup: Changing of the guard

United States routs Japan to win Women’s World Cup

USWNT offers memories of Wambach before WWC finale

Caught up in soccer mania? Check out this new sport!

Will the 1999 U.S. World Cup team’s legacy live on?

U.S. vs. Japan: Chance to take back the Cup

LaMarcus Aldridge to join Spurs in West shake-up

Hot dog eating champ Joey Chestnut thinks he can eat 70 hot dogs this year

DeAndre Jordan turns down Clippers for Mavericks

2015 Women’s World Cup: Injury update on Morgan Brian

Senior bowler, 87, gears up for Senior National Games

Young Soccer Players Root for Carli Lloyd

Coke Zero 400 preview

MLB Fantasy Focus: Miguel Sano packs some power

NBA Daily Hype: Franchise players staying put

Cancer survivor runs through Monroe County

NFL Daily Blitz: Pro Bowlers handed suspensions

2015 Women’s World Cup: American Pride

Dwyane Wade to return to Heat

Damian Lillard agrees to max deal with Trail Blazers

Greg Monroe agrees to contract with Bucks

Headline Hunting: McGregor, Mendes, Aldo and more

Tim Duncan returning to Spurs for 19th season

How do Nathan’s competitors eat hot dogs so fast?

Hallice Cooke working his way back from injuries

NFL Daily Blitz: Cowboys not worried about replacing Murray

Overtime: 9 MLB stars who need to bring back their glorious mustaches

NBA Daily Hype: Free agent frenzy

MLB Fantasy Focus: Fantasy Baseball June MVPs

Women’s World Cup preview: U.S. vs. Japan in final rematch

Recapping a busy first day of NBA free agency

Hot dog still king of Independence Day

How the Lakers can get back in playoff contention

Kevin Love returns to Cavaliers for ‘unfinished business’

Sabres to draft Jack Eichel with 2nd pick

Ovince Saint Preux on fighting Glover Teixeira in Nashville

Goran Dragic agrees to deal with the Heat

Biggest potential steals among NBA free agents

NFL Daily Blitz: Russell Wilson’s contract won’t impact play

MLB Fantasy Focus: Pitchers returning from injuries

How Wimbledon’s grass started favoring Nadal and Djokovic

NBA Daily Hype: Sought after big men

Kawhi Leonard agrees to deal with the Spurs

Anthony Davis gets contract extension

Will Shortz: Table tennis iron man

U.S. downs Germany, earns trip to Women’s World Cup final

Rousey on involvement with new Reebok kits

American Outlaws: Why soccer should be our passion

Fan Perspective: should Yoel Romero be reprimanded? And thoughts on the new UFC Fight Kit

UFC unveils Reebok fighter kit

Jessica Aguilar on being stuck in WSOF, watching UFC strawweights

Perfect fits for NBA free agents

Conor McGregor readies for war, against whomever that may be

Duke Roufus gives his advice for finding a good gym

Riskiest big-money NBA free agents

MLB Fantasy Focus: How do you replace Giancarlo Stanton?

NBA Daily Hype: Will marquee players stick with current teams?

Best to watch this week with Bill Bellamy

Jessica Springsteen on her Olympic equestrian hopes

The Speed Bag: Aldo fighting starting to sound like a bad idea

Conor McGregor on martial arts, confidence jiu-jitsu

0) { %

0) { %

0) { %

<!–

Article source: Article Source

The post Judge orders cancellation of Redskins trademark appeared first on .

Show more