The debate over the value of music-streaming services continues to proliferate, with Talking Heads frontman David Byrne becoming the latest artist to lambast Spotify for its business model.
Byrne, 61, wrote an essay on The Guardian’s website that criticizes the lack of money flowing into artists’ pockets for Spotify’s use of their work. The singer said he supports protestations made by musicians like Thom Yorke, who removed Atoms for Peace’s music from the service and last week encouraged those in the industry to “fight the Spotify thing.”
Byrne’s thesis is best summed up here:
“The inevitable result would seem to be that the internet will suck the creative content out of the whole world until nothing is left. … For a band of four people that makes a 15% royalty from Spotify streams, it would take 236,549,020 streams for each person to earn a minimum wage of $15,080 (£9,435) a year. For perspective, Daft Punk’s song of the summer, ‘Get Lucky,’ reached 104,760,000 Spotify streams by the end of August: the two Daft Punk guys stand to make somewhere around $13,000 each. Not bad, but remember this is just one song from a lengthy recording that took a lot of time and money to develop. That won’t pay their bills if it’s their principal source of income. And what happens to the bands who don’t have massive international summer hits?”
The Talking Heads singer and “How Music Works” author goes on to question the discoverability of new artists via Spotify — something some acts champion — as well as whether streaming services are simply profitable versions of illegal entities “such as Napster and Pirate Bay.”
“I don’t have an answer,” Byrne concludes. “I wish I could propose something besides what we’ve heard before: ‘Make money on live shows.’ Or, ‘Get corporate support and sell your music to advertisers.’ What’s at stake is not so much the survival of artists like me, but that of emerging artists and those who have only a few records under their belts.”
Read Byrne’s incisive essay over on The Guardian.
Loading Slideshow
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Sandra Bullock arrived for the premiere of her new film “Gravity” at the 57th BFI London Film Festival on Oct. 10.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Khloe Kardashian supported Kenny ‘Babyface’ Edwards as he received a star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame on Oct. 10.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
“Grey’s Anatomy” actress Sandra Oh stopped by the ABC studios to appear on “Good Morning America” on Oct. 10 in New York City.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Kelly Clarkson attended the American Music Awards Nominees Announcement at BB King’s Club in New York City on Oct. 10.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
“Rent” co-stars Rosario Dawson and Taye Diggs attended the Men’s Health 25th anniversary celebration at Isola, Mondrian Soho Hotel on Oct. 9 in New York City.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Hayden Panettiere showed off her huge diamond engagement ring as she returned to the Trump Soho Hotel on October 9 in New York City.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Kris Jenner flashed a big smile as she left an office building in Los Angeles, Calif., on Oct. 9, the day after announcing her separation from husband Bruce Jenner.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Tom Hanks and Rita Wilson posed at the European premiere of “Captain Phillips” on the opening night of the 57th BFI London Film Festival at Odeon Leicester Square on Oct. 9 in London.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
A sparkling Kate Hudson shined in a disco ball broken glass dress for a photo shoot in Los Angeles, Calif., on Oct. 8.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Miley Cyrus signed copies of her CD “Bangerz” at Planet Hollywood in New York City Oct. 8.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Lea Michele met Jane Lynch and Matthew Morrison of “Glee” for lunch at the Four Seasons in Los Angeles, Calif., on Oct. 8.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Jessica Alba was seen outside Breakfast Television and the CBC building, promoting her ‘The Honest Company’ baby products in Toronto on Oct. 8.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Jude Law signed autographs for fans outside the BBC Radio One studios on Oct. 8 in London.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Abbie Cornish attended the MIPCOM party during MIPCOM 2013 in Cannes, France on Oct. 7.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Stacy Keibler hit the road on the Can-Am Spyder, celebrating with an early birthday ride in the open air in Los Angeles, Calif., on Oct. 7.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Khloe Kardashian and Rapper The Game arrived at Tru Night Club in Los Angeles, Calif., on Oct. 7.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Zooey Deschanel filmed a scene on the beach for her hit show “The New Girl” in Malibu, Calif., on Oct. 7.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Hilary Swank and her boyfriend Laurent Fleury were seen holding hands after a tennis practice in a local park by the Hudson River in Downtown, Manhattan on Oct. 7.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Jackie Chan and Nicole Kidman attended the opening ceremony of the 10th Huading Awards on Oct. 7 in Macao, China.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Miley Cyrus performs live on NBC’s “Today” show in Rockefeller Center on October 7, 2013 in New York City
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Selena Gomez stopped to get some gas before heading to a dance studio in Tarzana, Calif., on Oct. 6.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Keith Urban announced the world premiere of The URBAN Guitar Collection — debuting live on HSN Nov. 3 — on Oct. 4 in Tampa, Fla.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Katherine Heigl and husband Josh Kelley looked smitten after lunch at Bubby’s restaurant in TriBeCa, NYC, on Oct. 4.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Brad Pitt and Shia LaBeouf filmed their new movie ‘Fury’ in Oxfordshire, England on October 4.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Kim Kardashian posted a photo on Oct. 4 of her daughter, North, who is almost four months old.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Newly engaged Naya Rivera attended the Latina Magazine ‘Hollywood Hot List’ party at The Redbury Hotel in Hollywood on Oct. 3.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Controversial celebrity photographer Terry Richardson released a series of risque photos of Miley Cyrus on Oct. 3. In them, Cyrus is seen licking a mirror, smoking, and stripping.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Penelope Cruz stunned at a special screening of “The Counselor” at Odeon West End in London on October 3, just two and a half months after welcoming baby girl Luna.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Christina Milian looked beautiful as she stepped out for dinner in West Hollywood, Oct. 3.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Julianne Moore was honored with a star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame on Oct. 3 in Los Angeles.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Newlywed Chrissy Teigen, wearing knee-high brown leather boots with a grey top and blue denim hot pants, hailed a taxi in NYC on Oct. 3.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Gwyneth Paltrow filmed a Hugo Boss commercial in downtown Los Angeles on October 3.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Amanda Seyfried and her denim cutoff shorts took Finn for a walk in New York City on October 3.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Cate Blanchett was peach perfection at the New York Film Festival Gala Tribute held in her honor Oct. 2 in New York.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Kerry Washington looked fierce as she headed in for ‘The Late Show with David Letterman’ taping in New York City, Oct. 2.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Bethenny Frankel did some paddle boarding in the Hudson River in New York City on Oct. 2.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
A bespectacled Katy Perry was seen leaving Colette’s store on October 2, in Paris, France.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Khloe Kardashian was spotted filming “Keeping Up With the Kardashians” outside Katsuya Restaurant on October 2, in Encino, Calif.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Jennifer Hudson made her way to a taping ‘Good Morning America’ in Times Square, NYC, Oct. 2. She looked incredible in a tight red dress and black peeptoe booties.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Julianne Hough spotted chatting on her phone while out and about in New York City, October 1.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Ben Stiller and Naomi Watts spotted on the set of ‘While We’re Young’ in New York City, October 1.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
A newly blonde Ashley Greene attended the screening Of Xlrator Media’s ‘CBGB’ at ArcLight Cinemas in Los Angeles, Oct. 1.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Ashlee Simpson was seen leaving Vignette Lounge in Hollywood on Oct 1.
Celebrity Photos: October 2013
Sarah Michelle Geller posed outside ‘Late Show With David Letterman’ in New York City, October 1.
Celebrity Photos: September 2013
Kimye stepped out for dinner in Paris Sept. 30, and Kim stunned in a tight leather skirt paired with a casual white top.
Celebrity Photos: September 2013
Ashton Kutcher and Mila Kunis arrived on a flight at LAX airport in Los Angeles, Calif., on Sept. 29.
Celebrity Photos: September 2013
Liam Hemsworth was seen out and about in New York City on Sept. 28.
Celebrity Photos: September 2013
Reportedly pregnant Gwen Stefani stepped out in Studio City, California September 27 after dropping off her son Zuma at school .
Celebrity Photos: September 2013
Rosie Huntington-Whiteley and Jason Statham arrive in London September 27, debunking all speculation that they have broken up.
Celebrity Photos: September 2013
Rihanna wore all black as she touched down in Adelaide, Australia on Sept. 26.
Celebrity Photos: September 2013
Rooney Mara carried her little black dog as she made her way out of LAX in Los Angeles, Calif., on Sept. 26.