Let's start with the story itself. Carl Mays - sympathetic figure or bad guy? Do you think Mike Sowell provided a balanced account or tried to make Mays look worse than he was?
What did you think of the depiction of the 1920 pennant race and the role of the beaning in the context of the Indians season?
What did you enjoy the most about the story? Least? Did Sowell make you want to learn more about anything?
We'll start with that for now. I'll refrain from commenting until others have commented and put them all together into one nice post.