prettydirtysecretliar:
thebestplltheories:
NOTE: RE-BLOGGING THIS POST FROM ME WILL ENSURE THE MOST RECENT AND UP TO DATE POST. I AM CONSTANTLY EDITING AND UPDATING THIS WITH MORE QUESTIONS (AND ANSWERS WHEN WE GET THEM), so whilst it’s great you share it around (please do!), please remember that I AM THE ONE EDITING so check back to THIS post for the edits!
Here are (what started out to be) 50 questions across all seasons that have not been answered and still need to be answered before the series finale (7x20).
At the end of every episode of season 7, I will re-blog this and update it with answers. I quote Marlene: “reveals on a week by week basis” for season 7.
Please get involved in this too! Send me questions I missed, or answers I haven’t updated yet! This is a group effort that we will all contribute to; crossing these off for this final season!
Here’s to hoping that we can cross off all of these by the end!!
Extremely obvious questions that we WILL get answers to, definitely, are first. Who is Uber A/AD?
We know Uber A became A to avenge Charlotte’s death. Why is Charlotte’s death so important to this person? What was their relationship?
What are Mary and Rollins up to?
Who killed Charlotte? Why isn’t Uber A attacking THAT person? Why attack the liars over this?
Who killed Jessica?
Rollins says he married Ali so that he can avenge Charlotte’s death, but he was already seducing Ali before Charlotte had even died. This makes no sense. Clearly, there is an ulterior motive here.
What’s up with Rollins and Charlotte being a thing? When and why? Rollins was into Ali and Charlotte?
Everything about Bethany Young. Why haven’t we seen her face, how was she identified as Alison in the grave all those years ago, why did Jessica want her to call her Aunt Jessy, why was she in Radley, etc. I think I have all these answers as per my master theory (check blog description for a link to the theory), but it does need to be confirmed in the show.
Which boy pulled a gun on Ali? (flashback in 4x11) Is this important or irrelevant?
Why was Wren colouring in a red coat?
Is there a reason Eddie recognised Aria at Radley, or was that just a friendly coincidence?
“We’re not having the same problems again, are we Eddie?” said Wren. Then Eddie said “from the minute that guy got here, it wasn’t for the right reasons”. What is going on between Wren and Eddie?
“We have a problem, you take care of your end and I’ll take care of my end.” - Wren. Explain please, Marlene.
Who was in Jason’s house in season 2? Remember we saw a shadow and blood in the trash.
Why was Jessica at Aunt Carol’s house and who was she hiding in the house? Remember how Jason heard noises from inside. What if this wasn’t Jessica at Aunt Carol’s house, but was Mary, hiding Rollins inside?
Are they ever going to address the fact that Rollins was Mona’s doctor in Radley too? Is this significant or not?
Who attacked Ali at Halloween? I don’t think this was Mona. I would LOVE it if this was AD, and AD was the original attacker who started it all.
Marlene tweeted recently that there might be more to the Maya storyline. I hope this is in relation to Miss Aria You’re A Killer Not Ezra’s Wife (Maya Knew). [I would just like to point out the foreshadowing there to Aria killing Shana!] I don’t like Marlene’s answer that Maya knew Nate was in Rosewood. What did Maya know!?
Where is Eddie!!? We last saw him delivering a drawing made by Bethany - next day he’s gone. Clearly, there is a mystery surrounding Bethany.
Who was the man and woman in the doll shop in 2x24 that wanted to hurt Ali, that “Seth-baby” was talking about? Mary and Rollins?
My biggest question: if CeCe was a patient at Radley, why did she need a visitor’s pass? This can be answered if they reveal that CeCe lied in 6x10, and Jessica never took her back to Radley after Charles’ funeral. She said she went back to Radley to add to her sob-story but instead was roaming the streets of Radley becoming A.
Why were members of the NAT club slowing being killed? What is up with that club? Such an awesome storyline from season 1 that was just randomly dropped. I hope they can continue this, and say that maybe the NAT club caught Mary Drake on tape, and she began killing members who saw her.
Which brings the next question: where has Mary been all this time? Why are we only hearing of her 6 seasons later?
Did CeCe know she was adopted? She must have known, since she chose the name CeCe DRAKE, obviously using her mother’s name. So then why did she lie to Ali in 6x10 about being sisters? Her whole motive for being A was to bring Ali home safely because she missed her sister; so is there another motive she hadn’t told us given they’re not actually sisters but cousins?
Sara Harvey!? Everything about her needs to be answered. Obviously, in particular, why she helped CeCe, and what she was doing in 6B staying in CeCe’s old room at Radley (and also the big hole in her room). She’s doing some investigating of her own, but why? And is she really that angry at the liars for being electrocuted? That wasn’t the liars’ fault!
Jason says he saw CeCe that night, but CeCe said that wasn’t her. Jason clearly saw someone but just got the face wrong. His eyesight was blurry, but it wasn’t making stuff up that wasn’t there. Who was Melissa talking to!?
Who was the person in the baseball cap who was talking to Melissa in 5B, that Spencer caught on her camera?
Why even tell us that Andrew is adopted? I hope the answer is not because they wanted us to think he was Charles, and that’s all.
Why did Lucas and Jenna go to prom together? What’s going on there?
Why did Leslie have 765432 pairs of glasses?
How was CeCe listed as Prom Queen if she didn’t even go to the school? Marlene, don’t tell me she just hacked the school’s system.
Wilden was paid off by Jessica to keep quiet about what Charlotte did to Ali. So then why was he so determined to pin it on the liars in season 1 if he already knew the answer? Maybe he was trying to frame someone else so that he can let his guilty conscience go free? Or did he not know what Charlotte did to Ali? Surely he could’ve put two and two together: someone is paying me to say CeCe wasn’t in Rosewood, on the same night a murder took place!? So what’s up with the “rest assured, I will find out what happened that summer”!? He already knew!?
The Sydney Driscol storyline went absolutely no where. Remember how they were making us think she is Jenna’s twin/sister? Why!?
Who was the fourth person to the picnic with Jenna, Sydney and Mona? What were they discussing?
What is Ali’s sexuality? She is married to Rollins so we can assume straight or bi. But does she have feelings for Emily?
Rhys Matthews. What was his purpose in the show? They went through a lot of effort to cast a Jason-look-alike.
Mona killed Bethany and had no punishments?
Who put the “Chandelier’s Rituals, sister launched lair, A ruler’s list chained” note in Mona’s room? This is an anagram to Charles DiLaurentis, BUT, do the individual words have meaning too? SISTER launched lair is intriguing, given we know there’s a twin SISTER now.
“You know me Spencer, you killed me”. Why did CeCe send this note to Spencer? Makes no sense. It almost seems like CeCe was forcing Spencer to believe she killed Ali or Bethany. But why was that her plan?
There was a continual theme of A loving Aria’s pink hair. This seems odd now knowing it is CeCe. The only person who loved Aria’s pink hair was Jason, and he’s not A? A tiny detail, but I hate inconsistencies.
Why was Melissa helping Jenna and Shana that night at the lodge? Are we supposed to believe what she said in 404 that she was just there spying on them to protect Spencer? It’s not “spying” if you’re working with the enemy.
How the hell did CeCe get the vials of blood in Spencer’s bag in London? This just screams Wren to me.
Not to mention the British spelling of “Nosey Bitches Die”? Why did Mona spell it like that?
Who burnt Cyrus? WHY? What even happened to Cyrus? What was his purpose on the show?
Marlene, please clarify the whole Varjack thing. I got NO idea. Was that CeCe? Why use that name? Ugh I don’t get it. This is actually a mess and an embarrassment on the writer’s behalf to start a storyline like this and INSTANTLY drop it within one episode.
“One of you has been touched by the one Alison feared the most”. This can’t be in reference to Aria and Ezra, because Alison didn’t fear Ezra. Was it in reference to Aria and CeCe/A who literally just touched each other half a minute ago (when Aria grabbed onto CeCe to prevent her from falling)? I think this is the answer, but I’d love a confirmation. (Probably on Twitter, Marlene, it would be awkward to raise this conversation back into the show after a 5 year time jump).
Ghost girl in Hanna’s house in 3x13? I don’t like Supernatural stuff. This needs to be explained.
Is there a reason, or story-line application of Alison’s twin story she told in 2x12? Mary and Jessica? Did one stab the other and send her to a mental asylum; Radley, like in her story?
Was the Radley car outside the DiLaurentis home in 2x12 for Mary?
Who killed Mrs. Potter and WHY? That’s so damn random.
Is there a reason Wilden had 2 passports and no personal effects in his apartment?
Jason spoke to someone on the phone saying “meet me in the parking lot in 15 minutes”, and is seen writing a check for $50,000. Then Wilden shows up. Did Jason give that money to Wilden? WHY? Did Wilden have Ali’s remains (that’s what Jason was asking for to get the money).
Why was Bethany wearing an Alison bracelet when she died? Someone clearly went to extreme efforts to make sure Bethany looks like Ali. Further, how was she mis-identified as Ali? Are their DNA similar? It’s possible if Bethany is Mary’s other daughter. Or, was someone on the police force altering the reports?
CeCe said in 610 that “mum didn’t know CeCe was Charlotte until the day we left for Cape May”. Hold on a second. Jessica couldn’t work out that CeCe DRAKE is her niece? The bitch was using the same name as her maiden name/twin sister’s name! Also, remember that time Jessica said “it wasn’t my daughter sitting in Radley it was CeCe Drake”. DRAKE. Jessica knew CeCe was a Drake; was Charlotte, yet she said nothing. She practically allowed incest. This tells me CeCe was lying in 610. She had some ulterior motive and I’m so excited to find out what that is. Why was she lying!?
#21 and #31 :
I don’t think Charlotte was a patient at Radley. I think Bethany is Charles (fits the age, Mary had Charles 25 years ago), and Charlotte is her sister. Charlotte stole Bethany’s story to make Ali feel sorry for her.
Because she never was a patient, Charlotte needed a visitor’s pass to see Mona. Wren even said that he allowed her to see Mona because Melissa asked him to. That’s also how Charlotte was able to become Prom Queen, have a roommate, go to UPenn, have a job, date Jason and go to Cape May with Ali, Wilden and Melissa.
Also, I think Charlotte killed Marion while visiting her mom and Charles at Radley. Because Charlotte visited so often, she got to know Radley really well, and that’s how she gave Mona a way in and out of that place, like Mona said she did.