It’s that time again. We’ve added a number of whiskeys to our ever-growing list of tasting notes and reviews since we last gathered them all up in one place. Check out the latest update with over 100 whiskeys rated for your enjoyment!
Updated as of March 28th, 2016. Check back often with ModernThirst.com for new reviews and tasting notes, and if there is a particular whiskey you’d like to see us tackle, please contact and us we’ll do our best to get to it! We’re always pouring! Cheers!
Click the score on the right to be taken to individual reviews.
*Click here to read about our scoring system*
Whiskey
Family
Proof
Rating
1792 Ridgemont Reserve
Barton
93.7
86
A Midwinter Nights Dram Act 2.9 Scene 710
High West
98.6
90
Ancient Age 80 (#BBBR)
Buffalo Trace
80
75
Ancient Age 90 (#BBBR)
Buffalo Trace
90
79
Ancient Ancient Age 10 Star (#BBBR)
Buffalo Trace
90
80
Barterhouse
Diageo/New Bernheim
90.5
85
Basil Hayden's
Jim Beam
80
82
Bernheim Wheat Whiskey Small Batch (Comparison Review)
Heaven Hill
90
87
Bernheim Wheat Whiskey (private barrel selection)
Heaven Hill
90
83
Bernheim Wheat Whiskey Liquor Barn Private Selection
Heaven Hill
90
88
Black Ridge
Barton
90
85
Blade & Bow
Diageo
90
88
Blade & Bow 22 Year
Diageo
90
90
Blanton's
Buffalo Trace
93
89
Booker's
Jim Beam
127
90
Buffalo Trace
Buffalo Trace
90
88
Bulleit 10 Year Bourbon
Diageo
91.2
88
Bulleit Bourbon
Diageo
90
86
Bulleit Rye
Diageo
90
87
Col. E. H. Taylor, Jr. Single Barrel
Buffalo Trace
100
88
Col. E. H. Taylor, Jr. Small Batch
Buffalo Trace
100
88
Colonel E. H. Taylor, Jr. Barrel Proof (2014)
Buffalo Trace
129
92
Double Rye!
High West
92
90
Eagle Rare (2014 Label/Batched)
Buffalo Trace
90
84
Eagle Rare (Pre 2014 Label, Single Barrel)
Buffalo Trace
90
89
Elijah Craig Barrel Proof
Heaven Hill
134.6
91
Elijah Craig Small Batch (12 Year)
Heaven Hill
94
89
Elmer T. Lee
Buffalo Trace
90
89
Evan Williams (Black Label) (#BBBR)
Heaven Hill
86
82
Evan Williams Barrel Proof
Heaven Hill
125
91
Evan Williams Master Distillers Select
Heaven Hill
90
88
Evan Williams Single Barrel Vintage 2003
Heaven Hill
86
88
Evan Williams Single Barrel Vintage 2004 (Society selection)
Heaven Hill
86
89
Evan Williams White Label (#BBBR)
Heaven Hill
100
86
Ezra Brooks Single Barrel 12 Year
Luxco/Heaven Hill
99
88
Flatboat
Barton
90
87
Forged Oak
Diageo/New Bernheim
90.5
NR
Four Roses LE Small Batch (2014)
Four Roses
103.2
92
Four Roses LE Small Batch 125th Anniversary (2013)
Four Roses
136.1
96
Four Roses Limited Edition Single Barrel (2014), OESF
Four Roses
113
95
Four Roses Single Barrel
Four Roses
100
88
Four Roses Single Barrel Private Selection Barrel Strength OBSV (Whiskey Women/Liquor Barn)
Four Roses
110.4
89
Four Roses Single Barrel Private Selection Barrel Strength OESF (Liquor Barn)
Four Roses
110.4
94
Four Roses Single Barrel Private Selection OESQ (Liquor Barn)
Four Roses
118
89
Four Roses Small Batch
Four Roses
90
87
Garrison Brothers Bourbon (Fall 2013 Vintage)
Garrison Brothers
94
83
George T. Stagg, 2009 Bottling
Buffalo Trace
141.4
95
Hancock's President's Reserve
Buffalo Trace
88.9
87
Hartfield & Co. -The Gentleman Whiskey
Hartfield & Co.
100
NR
Heaven Hill 6 Year Bottled in Bond (comparison)
Heaven Hill
100
86
Henry McKenna Single Barrel Private Selection (Liquor Barn)
Heaven Hill
100
88
I.W. Harper 15 year Bourbon
Diageo
86
91
I.W. Harper Kentucky Straight Bourbon (4 years)
Diageo
82
84
Jack Daniel's Single Barrel Barrel Proof
Brown-Forman
132.3
90
Jefferson's Chef's Collaboration
Jefferson
90
84
Jefferson's Ocean Voyage 3
Jefferson
90
89
Jefferson's Presidential Select 25 Year
Jefferson
90.4
84
Jim Beam Harvest Collection Soft Red Wheat
Jim Beam
90
84
Kentucky Tavern Bottled-in-Bond
Barton
100
85
Kentucky Vintage
KBD/Willett
90
78
Knob Creek
Jim Beam
100
86
Knob Creek Single Barrel Reserve
Jim Beam
120
90
Larceny
Heaven Hill
92
86
Lost Prophet
Diageo/GTS-Buffalo Trace
90.5
90
Maker's Mark Cask Strength
Maker's Mark
113.2
90
Maker's Mark
Maker's Mark
90
86
Maker's Mark Private Select Liquor Barn #1
Maker's Mark
110.1
93
Maker's Mark Private Select Liquor Barn #2
Maker's Mark
110
92
Masterson's Rye Whiskey
35 Maple
90
82
McAffee's Benchmark Old. No. 8 (#BBBR)
Buffalo Trace
80
75
Michter's Small Batch US*1
Michter's
91.4
87
Noah's Mill
KBD/Willett
114.4
89
Old Crow (#BBBR)
Jim Beam
80
72
Old Fitzgerald 12 year
Heaven Hill
90
88
Old Fitzgerald BiB 100 (#BBBR)
Heaven Hill
100
83
Old Forester 1870 Original Batch
Brown-Forman
90
92
Old Forester 1897 Bottled-in-Bond
Brown-Forman
100
90
Old Forester Birthday Bourbon 2014
Brown-Forman
97
90
Old Forester Signature
Brown-Forman
100
88
Old Forester Single Barrel- The Bourbon Society selection
Brown-Forman
90
87
Old Grand Dad BiB 100 (#BBBR)
Jim Beam
100
76
Old Grand-Dad 114
Jim Beam
114
86
Old Taylor (#BBBR)
Buffalo Trace
80
69
Old Weller Antique (Liquor Barn)
Buffalo Trace
107
85
OldTub
Jim Beam
100
84
Parker's Heritage 7th edition, Promise of Hope (2013)
Heaven Hill
96
93
Parker's Heritage Collection 8th Edition Wheat Whiskey (2014)
Heaven Hill
127.4
95
Parker's Heritage Collection 9th Edition Malt Whiskey (2015)
Heaven Hill
108
88
Pikesville Rye Whiskey
Heaven Hill
110
92
Rittenhouse Rye Bottled-in-Bond
Heaven Hill
100
91
Rock Hill Farms Single Barrel
Buffalo Trace
100
90
Rowan's Creek
KBD/Willett
100.1
86
Single Oak Project Barrel 175
Buffalo Trace
90
90
Single Oak Project barrel 77
Buffalo Trace
90
85
Smooth Ambler Old Scout 10 year Bourbon
Smooth Ambler
99
89
Smooth Ambler Old Scout 7 year Bourbon
Smooth Ambler
99
87
Smooth Ambler Old Scout 8 year Bourbon
Smooth Ambler
106.8
86
Smooth Ambler Old Scout Rye Whiskey
Smooth Ambler
99
88
Smooth Ambler Old Scout Single Barrel Cask Strength Bourbon
Smooth Ambler
119.8
88
Smooth Ambler Old Scout Single Barrel Cask Strength Rye Whiskey
Smooth Ambler
124.42
92
Stagg jr. (2014)
Buffalo Trace
134.8
94
The Gifted horse
Diageo
115
85
The Quiet Man 8 Year Single Malt
Luxco/Niche Spirits
80
NR
The Quiet Man Traditional Blend
Luxco/Niche Spirits
80
NR
Very Old Barton BiB 100 (#BBBR)
Barton
100
83
Virginia Gentleman Small Batch
Smith Bowman
90
75
W.L. Weller Special Reserve (Liquor Barn)
Buffalo Trace
90
80
Wild Turkey 101
Wild Turkey
101
91
Wild Turkey Kentucky Spirit - Bourbon Society Selection
Wild Turkey
101
90
Wild turkey Russell's Reserve 6 Year Rye
Wild Turkey
90
82
Wild Turkey Russell's Reserve Single Barrel Private Selection (Westport Whiskey & Wine)
Wild Turkey
110
89
Willett Family Estate 4 Year Rye
KBD/Willett
110
90
Willett Family Estate Single Barrel 10 Year (Westport Whiskey & Wine)
KBD/Willett
126.2
93
Willett Family Estate Single Barrel 8 Year (Liquor Barn)
KBD/Willett
119.6
88
Willett Pot Still Reserve
KBD/Willett
94
87
Willett XCF Version 1.0
KBD/Willett
103.4
84
William Larue Weller (2013)
Buffalo Trace
110
94
Woodford Reserve Double Double Oaked
Woodford Reserve
90.4
89
Woodford Reserve Sweet Mash Redux
Woodford Reserve
90.4
78
The post All of our whiskey reviews in one place! appeared first on ModernThirst.