VfDs for "personal itineraries"
← Older revision
Revision as of 05:57, 24 March 2014
Line 1,045:
Line 1,045:
::: I believe we should work that out over time - let us focus working on a few "One day in Bangkok makes a hard man humble" articles and see how it pans out - what type of content did we have to remove, what to keep off limits and what rules of a thumb can we draw from that experience. Atm, I really really really don't see how "One day in X" are bad for WV, except for the fact that some are incomplete. But then, let's just complete them! [[User:PrinceGloria|PrinceGloria]] ([[User talk:PrinceGloria|talk]]) 05:43, 24 March 2014 (UTC)
::: I believe we should work that out over time - let us focus working on a few "One day in Bangkok makes a hard man humble" articles and see how it pans out - what type of content did we have to remove, what to keep off limits and what rules of a thumb can we draw from that experience. Atm, I really really really don't see how "One day in X" are bad for WV, except for the fact that some are incomplete. But then, let's just complete them! [[User:PrinceGloria|PrinceGloria]] ([[User talk:PrinceGloria|talk]]) 05:43, 24 March 2014 (UTC)
::: PS. I never saw a "flood" of those, much like anything, they have not seen nearly enough contributions. I wouldn't worry about more being created. I find them EXTREMELY useful as a traveller.
::: PS. I never saw a "flood" of those, much like anything, they have not seen nearly enough contributions. I wouldn't worry about more being created. I find them EXTREMELY useful as a traveller.
+
:::: See [[Wikivoyage talk:Itineraries#Tightening the criteria for an itinerary article]] for a list of twelve such articles that were created in a single week, leading to the current guidance against "X location in Y time" articles. -- [[User:Wrh2|Ryan]] • ([[User talk:Wrh2|talk]]) • 05:57, 24 March 2014 (UTC)
== Proposed related site external links and small technical issue ==
== Proposed related site external links and small technical issue ==