After reading your recommendations for some fantastic detectives, underrated crime books and books that would work well on the big screen, we had an inkling that there were a few fans of certain authors in our midst. As the crime period of #WHSBookmarks started to draw to an end, we decided to take it to the vote and cruelly ask you to narrow down all your favourite crime authors to choose just one to be the best crime author of all time. The nominations came pouring in, including a huge mix of authors, from the classics who are considered the godfathers/mothers of their sub-genre to modern bestsellers to little-heard-of names that have made a big impact on you. In the end though, our winner won the crown by a landslide, leaving us in no doubt as to who you think is worthy of the title of The Best Crime Author of all Time.
Scroll down to find out if your vote made the top 20.
#20 Stuart MacBride
Scottish crime writer Stuart MacBride claims the #20 spot with his intricate police procedurals and his authentic detective Logan McRae. Infusing the tension and suspense of crime fiction with a dark humour, MacBride’s novels create an intriguing contrast of emotions throughout, all set against the grimly painted backdrop of Aberdeen. His debut novel ‘Cold Granite’ won the Barry Award for best first novel and he was awarded the dagger in the library in 2007 by the Crime Writers’ Association.
Click here for more from Stuart MacBride.
#19 Thomas Harris
Thomas Harris is perhaps best known for his charming, cannibalistic villain Hannibal Lecter. Toying with FBI agent Clarice Starling with intelligence and sociopathic cruelty, Harris’s character is unique in that his notoriety is greater than the detective hunting him. The award-winning Hannibal Lecter books have since been adapted for film and TV with great success, most famously brought to life by Anthony Hopkins. Thomas Harris is known for being particularly private and protective of his personal life and has in fact not been interviewed since 1976.
Click here for more from Thomas Harris.
#18 P. D. James
P. D. James, Baroness James of Holland Park, OBE, FRSA, FRSL established herself as a leading voice in crime detective fiction during an outstanding career that saw her awarded an OBE and win the Mystery Writers of America Grandmaster Award in 1999. James’s most famous creation – Adam Dalgliesh – is a tall, dark and handsome example of a gentleman detective, and featured in 14 of her novels. At the start of her career Phyllis worked for both the NHS and the police, and used her experiences alongside extensive research to include authentic details in her work. Her characters have captivated many crime fans over the years and a huge hole has been left in the literary world since she sadly passed away in November 2014.
Click here for more from P. D. James.
#17 Simon Kernick
Simon Kernick has featured heavily in the voting throughout the Crime section of #WHSBookmarks with several of his books voted as the most underrated crime book and ‘Relentless’ appearing as the sixth most voted for crime book that should be made into a film. Simon is best known for his Tina Boyd series and Mike Bolt series, crafting tension and suspense expertly through intriguing characters and ever-thickening plots. Simon first broke onto the mainstream bookshelf with his Tina Boyd novel ‘Relentless‘ – which went on to become the best-selling thriller in the UK in 2007.
Click here for more from Simon Kernick.
#16 Lee Child
Lee Child has earned a fiercely loyal fan base with his lead character Jack Reacher, a rogue, ex-army major who seeks out criminals to get revenge for their crimes. Lee grabbed attention early on in his writing career, winning the Anthony award for best first novel with his debut book ‘Killing Floor’. Since then Lee has gone on to be awarded the Cartier Diamond Dagger for lifetime achievement by the Crime Writers’ Association and was elected president of the mystery writers of America in 2009. His previous experience in TV production seems to have influenced his gripping characters and action-fuelled scenes, and we’ve now even seen Jack Reacher brought to life by Tom Cruise in the film ‘Jack Reacher’.
Click here for more from Lee Child.
#15 Chris Carter
Brazilian writer Chris Carter studied psychology with specialisation in criminal behaviour and worked as a criminal psychologist before turning to music and writing. His books follow detective Robert Hunter, diving into unusual, graphic and haunting cases as Chris demonstrates his in-depth understanding of the criminal mind. Receiving several votes throughout the crime period of #WHSBookmarks, ‘One by One’ and ‘The Crucifix Killer’ have appeared both on our underrated crime books as voted by you list, and on our crime books we’d like to see on the big screen list along with ‘The Death Sculptor’.
Click here for more from Chris Carter.
#14 Karen Rose
American romance suspense novelist Karen Rose is hugely popular in both the US and UK and has won the RITA award twice. Her debut ‘Don’t Tell’ was released back in 2003, and since then she has gone on to publish a total of 16 novels within the same fictional world. With characters that feature across books, her novels can be read as standalone stories although there is a benefit to reading them in order. Karen’s unique blend of romance and suspense makes for engrossing reads, while her masterful control of pace and detail keeps you hooked until the end.
Click here for more from Karen Rose.
#13 Ruth Rendell
Ruth Rendell CBE is often credited as the author that first introduced psychological details of criminals and victims within crime fiction to the mainstream. As well as the novels that helped carve out a niche for psychological crime books, Ruth is also well known for her Chief Inspector Wexford police procedurals. She has received the Silver, Gold and Cartier diamond daggers from the Crime Writers’ Association as well as three Edgar Awards during her career, for work she published both under her real name and her pseudonym Barbara Vine. Sadly Ruth suffered a stroke in January 2015 and was last known to be in a critical but stable condition.
Click here for more from Ruth Rendell.
#12 Patricia Cornwell
Patricia Cornwell is the author behind the Dr Kay Scarpetta series and is often credited with bringing forensic science into mainstream crime fiction. Patricia worked in a chief medical examiner’s office herself for 6 years and has used her experiences to provide insightful and knowledgeable detail in her books. Her novels have received many awards over the years, and her debut ‘Postmortem’ resulted in her becoming the only author to receive the Edgar Award, John Creasey Memorial Award, Anthony Award and Macavity Award in the same year.
Click here for more from Patricia Cornwell.
#11 Mark Billingham
Mark Billingham first started out in acting, before moving onto comedy and then writing. His bestselling Tom Thorne series incorporates a sense of drama and humour that makes for well-rounded and engrossing reads. Since his first crime novel ‘Sleepyhead’ was published in 2001, Mark has gone on to become the first author to win the Theakston’s Old Peculier Crime Novel of the Year Award twice. Mark has also been inducted into the ITV3 Crime Thriller Awards Hall of Fame and won the Sherlock award for best detective novel by a UK author for ‘Scaredy Cat’.
Click here for more from Mark Billingham.
#10 Tess Gerritsen
Tess Gerritsen is a writer of medical and crime thrillers, and is perhaps best known for Rizzoli and Isles books which have been adapted into a TV series. Tess has a background in anthropology and medicine and is a retired physician which has leant itself well to the detail she provides in her medical thrillers. After originally publishing a number of romantic thrillers, Tess released her first medical thriller – Harvest – in 1996, which saw her debut on the New York Times bestseller list. In 2006 she won the Nero Award for best mystery novel and both James Patterson and Stephen King have praised her work.
Click here for more from Tess Gerritsen.
#9 Karin Slaughter
Karin Slaughter’s first novel ‘Blindsighted’ became an international success back in 2001, earning her an army of fans around the world that has continued to grow and grow. Karin is best recognised for her Will Trent series and Grant Country series and is often praised for depth and intricacy in her work.
Click here for more from Karin Slaughter.
#8 R. C. Bridgestock
R. C. Bridgestock is the name that husband and wife co-authors Robert (Bob) and Carol Bridgestock write under. Bob spent many years working in the police force, taking charge of 26 murder cases and even working on the Yorkshire Ripper case, while Carol also worked for the police in the admin department. Between them they have nearly 50 years of police experience, offering an authentic edge to their stories. The couple self-published their first book ‘Deadly Focus’ and were then picked up by a publisher who re-released their novel 2 years later. The writing duo created the character DI Jack Dylan, a down-to-earth and relatable detective, written with warmth and humour.
Click here for more from R. C. Bridgestock.
#7 Sheila Quigley
Sheila Quigley released her debut ‘Run for Home’ back in 2004, beginning her best loved series set in the fictional estate of Seahills. Sheila’s lead detective DI Lorraine Hunt has struck a chord with fans with her strong and tough female persona, and was even voted #10 in our top fictional detectives poll. Sheila is also the author of the more recent DI Mike Yorke series which has received praise-filled reviews from crimes fans.
Click here for more from Sheila Quigley.
#6 Martina Cole
Martina Cole is one of the most recognisable names in contemporary crime fiction, her stories often taking us into the dark and seedy underworld of London’s gangsters, sometimes within London Irish communities. Her fast-paced and action-packed novels usually follow a female protagonist, drawing us into the characters’ lives and motives to deliver sharp, punchy plot twists. Her novels usually hit the top of bestseller lists soon after release and many of her books have now been adapted into high-rating television dramas.
Click here for more from Martina Cole.
#5 Agatha Christie
The queen of crime fiction, Dame Agatha Christie has written 66 detective novels, and has even been credited with creating the motifs that we now expect of detective crime fiction. Her most famous characters – Miss Marple and Hercule Poirot – have become heroes of the genre, and in fact Poirot is the only fictional character to receive an obituary in the New York Times. Her astonishingly successful career has seen her appointed a CBE in 1956 which was promoted to a DBE in 1971. She has also served as president of the detection club in the 1950’s, and her book ‘The Murder of Roger Ackroyd’ was voted the best crime novel ever by a poll of 600 writers of the Crime Writers’ Association in 2013. The Guinness World Records lists her as the bestselling novelist of all time, having sold approximately 2 billion copies of her books. They don’t call her the queen of crime for nothing!
Click here for more from Agatha Christie.
#4 Ian Rankin
Ian Rankin OBE is considered a writer of tartan noir, setting his dark and brooding stories on the streets of Edinburgh. His most famous character – Inspector John Rebus – is particularly well-loved in the world of crime fiction and was even voted #2 in our poll of top detectives as voted by you. Ian has won the Edgar Award, had 10 of his Rebus novels adapted for TV and has won 4 Crime Writers’ Association Dagger Awards, including the prestigious Diamond Dagger in 2005.
Click here for more from Ian Rankin.
#3 Val McDermid
The last of many Scottish authors to feature on our list, Val McDermid has earned the third spot on our list with her suspense novels that are often classed as tartan noir. Well known for her investigative characters Dr. Tony, Lyndsay Gordon and Kate Brannigan, Val’s work is considered quite dark and graphic, sparing no details in her realistic portrayal of crime. Most notably Val has won the Crime Writers’ Association Gold Dagger for best crime novel of the year and her Tony Hill series was adapted to create the popular TV series ‘Wire in the Blood’. Val is also the co-founder of the world’s largest crime fiction festival, The Theakstons Old Peculier Crime Writing Festival and their novel of the year award.
Click here for more from Val McDermid.
#2 James Patterson
James Patterson is perhaps one of the best known names in modern literature having sold over 300 million copies of his books and achieving the Guinness World Record and the New York Times record for most bestselling hardcover fiction titles by a single author – including 19 consecutive no.1 New York Times bestselling novels. James has won multiple awards over the years, including the Edgar Award, the BCA Mystery Guild’s Thriller of the Year and the International Thriller of the Year Award. In his later years James has collaborated with other authors on much of his work, allowing him to achieve an impressive number of published novels under his name. His most recognised series include the Alex Cross novels, Michael Bennett and the Women’s Murder Club series.
Click here for more from James Patterson.
And the Best Crime Author of All Time as Voted by You is…
#1. Peter James
Peter James has effortlessly stolen the crown with an incredible number of votes. Best known for his Roy Grace novels, which have achieved seven consecutive UK Sunday Times #1s, James has won multiple awards for his work and had many of his books adapted for TV and stage. Embracing a supernatural element to much of his work, Peter’s novels are full of intriguing plot twists and memorable characters, drawing us into their stories with masterfully crafted suspense. Peter has served two consecutive terms as chairman of the UK Crime Writers’ Association and is now the Overseas Vice-President of International Thriller Writers in the USA. He is certainly a worthy winner!
Click here for more from Peter James.
Not everyone voted for made it into the top 20 of course. Here is the full list of authors you voted for.
1. Peter James
2. James Patterson
3. Val McDermid
4. Ian Rankin
5. Agatha Christie
6. Martina Cole
7. Sheila Quigley
8. R. C. Bridgestock
9. Karin Slaughter
10. Tess Gerritsen
11. Mark Billingham
12. Patricia Cornwell
13. Ruth Rendell
14. Karen Rose
15. Chris Carter
16. Lee Child
17. Simon Kernick
18. P. D. James
19. Thomas Harris
20. Stuart MacBride
21. Sir Arthur Conan Doyle
22. Matt Johnson
23. John Connolly
24. Dennis Lehane
25. Dan Brown
26. Henning Mankell
27. Jo Nesbo
28. Peter May
29. Harlan Coben
30. Gillian Flynn
31. Dick Francis
32. John Grisham
33. Sarah Hilary
34. Robert Galbraith/JK Rowling
35. Mandasue Heller
36. Linwood Barclay
37. Kimberley Chambers
38. N. J. Cooper
39. Michael Connelly
40. Nicci French
41. Faye Kellerman
42. Jeffrey Deaver
43. Kathy Reichs
44. Jonathan Kellerman
45. Colin Bateman
46. Ed McBain
47. Raymond Chandler
48. Reginald Hill
49. Sophie Hannah
50. Alan Bradley
51. Tana French
52. Patricia Highsmith
53. Terry Goodkind
54. Simon Tyone
55. Michael Robotham
56. Dean Koontz
57. Mo Hayder
58. Louise Penny
59. Britt Montero
60. Derek Landy
61. Dorothy L. Sayers
62. Brian Freeman
63. James Rollins
64. J. D. Robb
65. S. J. Watson
66. Jodi Picoult
67. Ransom Riggs
68. Stieg Larsson
69. Lindsey Davis
70. Elizabeth George
71. C. J. Sansom
72. Chris Brookmyre
73. Karen Long
74. Michael J. Malone
75. Lisa Gardner
76. Leigh Russell
77. Tom Rob Smith
78. Tim Weaver
79. Karin Fossum
80. Chaz Brenchley
81. Helen Giltrow
82. Jim Kelly
83. David Hosp
84. Andrea Camilleri
85. Sam Millar
86. Edgar Wallace
87. Dan Starkey
88. John Le Carre
89. Stephen King
90. Ellis Peters
91. Ann Cleeves
92. Deborah Harkness
93. Peter Robinson
94. Bill Todd
95. Ed James
96. Sophie Kinsella
97. James Sallis
98. Sara Paretsky
99. Josephine Tey
100. Margarey Allingham
101. Martin Cruz Smith
102. Jeff Abbott
103. Lee Weeks
104. John Harvey
105. James Lee Burke
106. Kathryn Erskine
107. Edgar Allan Poe
108. Cecelia Ahern
The post The Best Crime Authors of All Time as Voted by You appeared first on WHSmith Blog.