I
know what some of you are thinking: Does every young adult novel these
days have to be part of a dystopian trilogy? And I admit that the market
seems to be flooded. Regardless, some series do stand out above the
crowd.
As I wrote last summer when I reviewed Divergent,
the first in a futuristic series set in a crumbling Chicago, Veronica
Roth's character development and world building drew me into the story.
If you are totally unfamiliar with the series, see my earlier review for
the setup, which I won't repeat here. This post contains no spoilers
for Insurgent, but I can't avoid some spoilers for the first book.
Insurgent
picks up almost immediately after the first book ends. Sixteen-year-old
Tris Prior is still reeling from the initial battles of civil war in
which she was forced to use violence and in which she witnessed the
deaths of loved ones. There is little time for her to recover, however,
because her participation in the revolt was caught on camera, and the
central government has included her in their group of most-wanted
individuals.
It soon becomes apparent that Tris is
being hunted down for more than her use of a gun. In a society that
relies on conformity for keeping the peace, anyone--like Tris--who has a
strong free will is considered to be dangerous. Thus Insurgent
follows Tris and her allies as they struggle to stay alive while
attempting to find the key that will expose the central government's use
of mind control to keep its citizens in line.
Although I loved Divergent, I had mixed feelings about Insurgent.
I was pleased that Roth continued to developed Tris's world,
introducing additional characters and showing us surprising aspects of
individuals we thought we already knew. The use of and ongoing research
into mind-controlling drugs continued to fascinate me, prompting me to
consider a variety of ethical questions. In fact, many of the items in HarperTeen's discussion guide for the first book center around such issues (I didn't find a reading guide for Insurgent.)
The principal problem with Insurgent
is Tris's relationship with the boy who goes by the name of Four.
Although Tris is stronger and more independent than Bella (of the
Twilight books), the novel is still full of the angst of teen romance.
Tris and Four's on-again/off-again status changed so often, it was
getting difficult to keep track. Not only was it tiresome to read about
but it diluted the moments when Tris was forced to choose between
fulfilling her own desires and advancing the greater good. I felt the
relationship issues got in the way of the much more interesting societal
problems and distracted my attention from the twists and turns of the
larger plot.
Now you might be wondering if I plan to read book three. I do. First, the strength of the Divergent
gives me hope that book three will return to the roots of the series,
putting Tris and Four's romance on a side burner. Second, Insurgent ended on a major revelation about the world at large, and I really have to know what happens next.
I
listened to the unabridged audio edition (Harper Audio, 11 hr, 22 min)
read by Emma Galvin. Once again, Galvin demonstrated her skill at
conveying a wide range of teenage emotions. Her excellent pacing and
consistent characterizations added to my enjoyment of the story. If
Galvin is the narrator of the next book in the Divergent series, I'll be
sure to listen.
Buy Insurgent at an Indie or a bookstore near you. This link leads to an affiliate program.
Published by HarperCollins / Katherine Tegen Books, 2012
ISBN-13: 9780062024046
Rating: C+
Source: bought (see review policy)
Copyright © cbl for Beth Fish Reads, all rights reserved (see review policy)
Comments
I want to try more dystopian fiction (the only dys... by Belle Wong http://www.blogger.com/profile/12112894169429729531
I still have this one on my TBR pile..my main prob... by A Buckeye Girl Reads http://www.blogger.com/profile/08952103323793072580
I loved Divergent, but have had this one on my nig... by Sandy Nawrot http://www.blogger.com/profile/00564390728106776030
I still need to read Divergent, which I just got o... by Zibilee http://www.blogger.com/profile/07443338685890187334
Totally agree with you on every point of your revi... by rhapsodyinbooks http://www.blogger.com/profile/07041412748239010264
I had a few problems with Insurgent - although I t... by Tanya Patrice http://www.blogger.com/profile/10589001490828032365
Related Stories
Review: Collateral Damage by Stuart Woods
Imprint Friday: We Live in Water by Jess Walter
Review: The Tin Horse by Janice Steinberg