Also Misogyny:
← Older revision
Revision as of 23:33, 13 July 2013
(One intermediate revision by one user not shown)
Line 164:
Line 164:
In fact, the few female characters Matt Ward has created/ written fluff for either die or are about to die (for instance the WD issue introducing the new Chaos Daemon armies featured fluff about a High Elf Mage who was tricked and killed by daemons. First female character he introduces to the setting is created just to die).
In fact, the few female characters Matt Ward has created/ written fluff for either die or are about to die (for instance the WD issue introducing the new Chaos Daemon armies featured fluff about a High Elf Mage who was tricked and killed by daemons. First female character he introduces to the setting is created just to die).
−
A potentially potent example occurs in his latest work, the eldar codex supplement; Iyanden. The issue is Matt's fluff concerning Iyanna Arienal, Iyanden's most renowned Spiritseer. First we have this entry in Iyanden's timeline (page 35, Eldar codex supplement Iyanden; "...the Spiritseer Iyanna Arienal begins the preparations that she believes will cast the souls of Iyanden INTO THE INFINITY CIRCUIT, and hasten Ynnead's awakening."). The first implication is that Matt Ward, as stated earlier on this page, forgot that an infinity circuit ALREADY houses the souls of dead Eldar. This, however, makes the second implication more disturbing. It refers to "...the souls of Iyanden..." but it doesn't specify whether it's referring to departed souls or the souls of those STILL ALIVE. It makes Iyanna sound like she's planning a mass murder of Iyanden's living Eldar or a mass suicide. Either one violates the canon, as they are a dying race who go to great lengths to preserve Eldar lives (which is why Eldar, especially Iyanden's, summon the dead for war in the first place). In addition, it says something about Matt Ward's regard for women that his first female character reads like an upcoming suicide cult leader (She does share a combination of traits, derived from numerous psychological studies, with real-life suicide cult leaders: Charismatic; check. Superiority complex; check. Grand vision of the future; check. Fixation with death and morbid things; check. Traumatic past with ample opportunity for mental scarring; BIG, FUCKING CHECK) While this could just be due to the Grimdark nature of the 40k universe, the sexist implications remain due to Matt Ward's history with women in 40k's fluff.
+
A potentially potent example occurs in his latest work, the eldar codex supplement; Iyanden. The issue is Matt's fluff concerning Iyanna Arienal, Iyanden's most renowned Spiritseer. First we have this entry in Iyanden's timeline (page 35, Eldar codex supplement Iyanden; "...the Spiritseer Iyanna Arienal begins the preparations that she believes will cast the souls of Iyanden INTO THE INFINITY CIRCUIT, and hasten Ynnead's awakening."). The first implication is that Matt Ward, as stated earlier on this page, forgot that an infinity circuit ALREADY houses the souls of dead Eldar. This, however, makes the second implication more disturbing. It refers to "...the souls of Iyanden..." but it doesn't specify whether it's referring to departed souls or the souls of those STILL ALIVE. It makes Iyanna sound like she's planning a mass murder of Iyanden's living Eldar or a mass suicide. Either one violates the canon, as they are a dying race who go to great lengths to preserve Eldar lives (which is why Eldar, especially Iyanden's, summon the dead for war in the first place). In addition, it says something about Matt Ward's regard for women that his first female character reads like an upcoming suicide cult leader (She does share a combination of traits, derived from numerous psychological studies, with real-life suicide cult leaders: Charismatic; check. Superiority complex; check. Grand vision of the future; check. Fixation with death and morbid things; check. Traumatic past with ample opportunity for mental scarring; BIG, FUCKING CHECK) While this could just be due to the Grimdark nature of the 40k universe, the sexist implications remain due to Matt Ward's history with women in 40k's fluff
. It is possible that since Iyanden's Infinity Circuit is more or less the prototype it doesn't work the same as the latter ones used, combine with how often they need to raise the dead might mean most are not within the Infinity Circuit so its possible she's trying to lessen her craftworld's reliance the dead. And Ynnead's fluff has always read like a suicide cult he only awakens once every Eldar is dead after all
.
Whether he intended it or not, the argument that Ward is a misogynist has ammo to fire specifically because of logic holes like that, and the accusation clings to Ward the same way his early works do: It stains so much of what he's done that it's simply impossible to ignore. Considering that about 70% of the factions in 40K are sausage-fests, GW is probably just as much to blame as Brother Ward, though to what extent may never truly be known (although with rumors about GW ordering all women in group shots to be photoshop out...).
Whether he intended it or not, the argument that Ward is a misogynist has ammo to fire specifically because of logic holes like that, and the accusation clings to Ward the same way his early works do: It stains so much of what he's done that it's simply impossible to ignore. Considering that about 70% of the factions in 40K are sausage-fests, GW is probably just as much to blame as Brother Ward, though to what extent may never truly be known (although with rumors about GW ordering all women in group shots to be photoshop out...).
Line 171:
Line 171:
Despite one or two valid points, the previous editor seems to have a case of SMurf favouritism. Yes Space Marines are GW's poster boys. Yes, killing guard armies happens all the time. HOWEVER, the constant use of the Sister's for worfing is unnecessary. If a new faction was shown to be able to wipe the floor with a Space Marine army from time-to-time, it would be a more effective worf. In addition, not using a non-Imperium faction for the worfing seems to imply the (false) idea that no faction can compete with the Imperium's might. As for the loss of a SM chapter, this is the Imperium, where the loss of an entire PLANET with a population of billions can be written off as a bureaucratic error. The loss of an entire Space Marine chapter doesn't always have to be a huge event (the idea that it does is over-the-top favoritism talking), [[Squats|especially if entire races can disappear without even a whisper.]]
Despite one or two valid points, the previous editor seems to have a case of SMurf favouritism. Yes Space Marines are GW's poster boys. Yes, killing guard armies happens all the time. HOWEVER, the constant use of the Sister's for worfing is unnecessary. If a new faction was shown to be able to wipe the floor with a Space Marine army from time-to-time, it would be a more effective worf. In addition, not using a non-Imperium faction for the worfing seems to imply the (false) idea that no faction can compete with the Imperium's might. As for the loss of a SM chapter, this is the Imperium, where the loss of an entire PLANET with a population of billions can be written off as a bureaucratic error. The loss of an entire Space Marine chapter doesn't always have to be a huge event (the idea that it does is over-the-top favoritism talking), [[Squats|especially if entire races can disappear without even a whisper.]]
+
+
Tell that to Games-Workshop, even minor chapters get a book about their Deaths these days.
==Your Fault As Well==
==Your Fault As Well==